Promoting an object

[PJChan]

Hi, I browsed for a related question/answer without luck, so here it goes:

Is there a known pattern that would allow me to promote an object of class A
to subclass B which inherits from A?
In other words, how can I turn a point into a circle or a dog into a
dalmatian? I know I can do the other way around with casting.

Thanks in advance.
--
P.J. Chan

[Jon Skeet [C# MVP]]

PJChan <PJ****@discuss ions.microsoft. com> wrote:

Hi, I browsed for a related question/answer without luck, so here it goes:

Is there a known pattern that would allow me to promote an object of class A
to subclass B which inherits from A?
Well, the object itself can never change type.
In other words, how can I turn a point into a circle or a dog into a
dalmatian? I know I can do the other way around with casting.

The normal way would be to provide a constructor in the derived class
which takes a reference to an instance of the base class, and creates a
new object based on it.

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.co m>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too

[Octavio Hernandez]

PJ,

Provided that Dalmatian inherits from Dog, and the declarations:

Dog dog;
Dalmatian dm;

Stating

dog = dm;

is OK, but the other way around you must use:

dm = (Dalmatian) dog;

or

dm = dog as Dalmatian;

Regards - Octavio
"PJChan" <PJ****@discuss ions.microsoft. com> escribió en el mensaje
news:32******** *************** ***********@mic rosoft.com...

Hi, I browsed for a related question/answer without luck, so here it goes:

Is there a known pattern that would allow me to promote an object of class
A
to subclass B which inherits from A?
In other words, how can I turn a point into a circle or a dog into a
dalmatian? I know I can do the other way around with casting.

Thanks in advance.
--
P.J. Chan

[PJChan]

Thanks Jon,
the part of "creates a new object based on it" do you mean that it keeps a
private instance of the object or that somehow the constructor "returns" a
new instance of the subclass B based on the passed object (which is of class
A)?

I resolved the requirement temporarly using the former method, but would
really prefer to use the later. How do I construct the new instance? Some
form of copy or clone? Would you mind providing a simple example?

thks
Pedro
--
P.J. Chan
"Jon Skeet [C# MVP]" wrote:

PJChan <PJ****@discuss ions.microsoft. com> wrote:

Hi, I browsed for a related question/answer without luck, so here it goes:

Is there a known pattern that would allow me to promote an object of class A
to subclass B which inherits from A?

Well, the object itself can never change type.

In other words, how can I turn a point into a circle or a dog into a
dalmatian? I know I can do the other way around with casting.

The normal way would be to provide a constructor in the derived class
which takes a reference to an instance of the base class, and creates a
new object based on it.

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.co m>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too

[PJChan]

Thanks Octavio
following your second example I always get a Casting exception or a null (if
I use the "... as ...")

My understanding is that under C# you cannot typecast from class to subclass
just like that as private members would not necessarily be initialised
properly.

I don't mind using a construct like: objB = new SubClassB(objA)
but I don't know how to go about creating the new instance based on the
existing objA, and I don't know if it is possible that objB and objA share
everything that exists in class A but objB has the extensions supplied by
subclass B.

Thanks
Pedro

--
P.J. Chan
"Octavio Hernandez" wrote:

PJ,

Provided that Dalmatian inherits from Dog, and the declarations:

Dog dog;
Dalmatian dm;

Stating

dog = dm;

is OK, but the other way around you must use:

dm = (Dalmatian) dog;

or

dm = dog as Dalmatian;

Regards - Octavio
"PJChan" <PJ****@discuss ions.microsoft. com> escribió en el mensaje
news:32******** *************** ***********@mic rosoft.com...

Hi, I browsed for a related question/answer without luck, so here it goes:

Is there a known pattern that would allow me to promote an object of class
A
to subclass B which inherits from A?
In other words, how can I turn a point into a circle or a dog into a
dalmatian? I know I can do the other way around with casting.

Thanks in advance.
--
P.J. Chan

[Jon Skeet [C# MVP]]

PJChan <PJ****@discuss ions.microsoft. com> wrote:

the part of "creates a new object based on it" do you mean that it keeps a
private instance of the object or that somehow the constructor "returns" a
new instance of the subclass B based on the passed object (which is of class
A)?
That's up to the implementation. If everything's done via properties,
it could be either - although you'd want to think of the ramifications
of what it meant to change the value of a property of the new object,
for instance.
I resolved the requirement temporarly using the former method, but would
really prefer to use the later. How do I construct the new instance? Some
form of copy or clone? Would you mind providing a simple example?

It really depends on what access the derived class has to the base
class. If the derived class has access to a sort of "copy constructor"
of the base class which just copies the values of all the fields from
one object into the new one, that would make things easier. Otherwise,
you may need to set the values of properties.

In general, it's something I try to avoid needing - does your design
absolutely depend on it?

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.co m>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too