destructor not called

[Marcin201]

I have a class which uses a temporary directory for storing data. I
would like that directory to be removed when the class is no longer
used. I have tried removing the temporary directory from the class
destructor, however, it was never called. After I while I traced the
problem to the class having a reference to it's own function. Here is
a simplified model.

test.py
class Foo:
def __init__(self):
print "Hello"
self.f = self.fxn

def __del__(self):
print "Bye"

def fxn(self):
print "function"

a = Foo()

running python test.py I get
Hello

Is this an expected behavior or a bug in python? If this is expected
any suggestions for working around this. I would like to avoid having
to call the destructor explicitly.

Thanks,

Marcin

[Szabolcs Ferenczi]

On Sep 28, 6:00*pm, Marcin201 <marcin...@gmai l.comwrote:

I have a class which uses a temporary directory for storing data. *I
would like that directory to be removed when the class is no longer
used. *I have tried removing the temporary directory from the class
destructor, however, it was never called.

The RAII (Resource Acquisition Is Initialization) pattern is not
applicable to Python since the language concept is not suitable for
it. The __del__ is not a genuine destructor. In your case it might not
be performed when you expected it because there were still references
left around to the object. You must take care to break those
references.

However, you can apply the EAM (Execute Around Method) pattern in
Python to achieve the same effect. You can apply the EAM pattern with
help of the `with' statement:

with Foo() as a:
# work with `a'

In this case you must implement methods __enter__ and __exit__ instead
of __init__ and __del__. The method __enter__ must return an instance
of Foo.

You can achieve the same effect with try-finally block as well:

a = Foo()
try:
# work with `a'
finally:
# make `a' remove directories

Best Regards,
Szabolcs

[Roy Smith]

In article
<2a************ *************** *******@p25g200 0hsf.googlegrou ps.com>,
Marcin201 <ma*******@gmai l.comwrote:

I have a class which uses a temporary directory for storing data. I
would like that directory to be removed when the class is no longer
used. I have tried removing the temporary directory from the class
destructor, however, it was never called.

The short answer is that destruction in Python is non-deterministic (a rude
shock if you're used to C++). What you probably want is the new "with"
statement (http://docs.python.org/ref/with.html).

[Michel Leunen]

Marcin201 a écrit :

class Foo:
def __init__(self):
print "Hello"
self.f = self.fxn

Maybe self.f = self.fxn() is what you want. Note the '()'.

--
Michel Leunen
http://linux.leunen.com

[George Sakkis]

On Sep 28, 12:00*pm, Marcin201 <marcin...@gmai l.comwrote:

I have a class which uses a temporary directory for storing data. *I
would like that directory to be removed when the class is no longer
used. *I have tried removing the temporary directory from the class
destructor, however, it was never called. *After I while I traced the
problem to the class having a reference to it's own function. *Here is
a simplified model.

test.py
class Foo:
* * def __init__(self):
* * * * print "Hello"
* * * * self.f = self.fxn

* * def __del__(self):
* * * * print "Bye"

* * def fxn(self):
* * * * print "function"

a = Foo()

running python test.py I get
Hello

Is this an expected behavior or a bug in python? *If this is expected
any suggestions for working around this. *I would like to avoid having
to call the destructor explicitly.

Others have already replied to your main question; in short you
shouldn't rely on __del__ being called. Regardless, is there a (good)
reason for having an instance reference to the method ? Without
further information, that seems like a code smell.

George

[Marcin201]

Others have already replied to your main question; in short you

shouldn't rely on __del__ being called. Regardless, is there a (good)
reason for having an instance reference to the method ? Without
further information, that seems like a code smell.

I have dictionary of fxns to do import/export based on the type of
request from user so I can call self.Import['html'] or
self.Import['text'].

Thanks for everyones help.

Marcin