Debug vs. Release Executable size

[Pocket Rocket]

I am developing an application using Windows forms, C# and Visual
Studio.Net. The executable size remains the same whether I built the debug
or release version. Is it normal? Am I missing something? Thanks for ur
help.

PR

[Scott M.]

The physical size of the assembly will not always change when in release
mode, yet you may still get a better performing assembly.

Please do not cross-post your questions.
"Pocket Rocket" <po***********@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:u3**************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

I am developing an application using Windows forms, C# and Visual
Studio.Net. The executable size remains the same whether I built the debug or release version. Is it normal? Am I missing something? Thanks for ur
help.

PR

[Flare]

> > I am developing an application using Windows forms, C# and Visual

Studio.Net. The executable size remains the same whether I built the

debug

or release version. Is it normal? Am I missing something? Thanks for ur help.

I believe the debug information is located in the pdb file and only a little
amount of infomation about debuging is in the actual assembly..Correct me if
im wrong.

Regards Anders

[Scott M.]

You are correct. When you compile in release mode the .pdb file does not
get created.
"Flare" <no****@sorry.dk> wrote in message
news:%2***************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

I am developing an application using Windows forms, C# and Visual
Studio.Net. The executable size remains the same whether I built the debug

or release version. Is it normal? Am I missing something? Thanks

for ur help.

I believe the debug information is located in the pdb file and only a

little amount of infomation about debuging is in the actual assembly..Correct me if im wrong.

Regards Anders

[Gernot Frisch]

So, do I need the pdb file if I want to know the file+line where the
program crashes on a computer without VS installed?
-Gernot

[Scott M.]

I can't say (I do have VS.NET and don't use the .pdb file myself).
"Gernot Frisch" <[e-mail]> wrote in message
news:c0*************@ID-37212.news.uni-berlin.de...

So, do I need the pdb file if I want to know the file+line where the
program crashes on a computer without VS installed?
-Gernot

[Alvin Bruney [MVP]]

> So, do I need the pdb file if I want to know the file+line where the

program crashes on a computer without VS installed?
absolutely.
but your release product should not be in debug mode for performance and
possibly security resasons. the exception is when you have a special problem
you can send a debug version to the customer to enable you to better
troubleshoot the problem.

--
Regards,
Alvin Bruney [ASP.NET MVP]
Got tidbits? Get it here...
http://tinyurl.com/3he3b
"Gernot Frisch" <[e-mail]> wrote in message
news:c0*************@ID-37212.news.uni-berlin.de... So, do I need the pdb file if I want to know the file+line where the
program crashes on a computer without VS installed?
-Gernot

[Richard Grimes [MVP]]

Pocket Rocket wrote:

I am developing an application using Windows forms, C# and Visual
Studio.Net. The executable size remains the same whether I built the
debug or release version. Is it normal? Am I missing something?

In addition to what has already been posted on this subject bear in mind
that the compiler will add the [Debuggable] attribute to a debug build to
turn off JIT optimization and to tell the .NET runtime to track how objects
are used (and make this information available to the debugger). Thus, it is
not a good idea to use debug build assemblies in a production environment
because their performance will be impaired.

Richard
--
my email ev******@zicf.bet is encrypted with ROT13 (www.rot13.org)
sign up for my free .NET newsletter at
http://www.wd-mag.com/newsletters/

[Pavel Lebedinsky]

Release code should be built with /debug:pdbonly. This way you get
both optimizations and symbols.

I'm not sure if VS project editor allows you to set this option though.

"Alvin Bruney [MVP]" wrote:

So, do I need the pdb file if I want to know the file+line where the
program crashes on a computer without VS installed?
absolutely.
but your release product should not be in debug mode for performance and
possibly security resasons. the exception is when you have a special

problem you can send a debug version to the customer to enable you to better
troubleshoot the problem.