XML schemas .NET 2.0

[peter.moss]

I have an XML schema and I am trying to validate any XML document sent
against it.

Here's some of the code:
XmlReaderSettin gs xmlReaderSettin gs = new
XmlReaderSettin gs();
xmlReaderSettin gs.Schemas.Add( @"http://myschema/myschema.xsd",
"myschema.xsd") ;
xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationEv entHandler += new
ValidationEvent Handler(Validat ionEvent);

xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationTy pe = ValidationType. Schema;

xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationFl ags =
xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationFl ags |

XmlSchemaValida tionFlags.Repor tValidationWarn ings;
XmlReader xmlReader = XmlReader.Creat e(myXmlDocument ,
xmlReaderSettin gs);

while(xmlReader .Read());

Now, my problem is, if I specify an XML document which breaks the
schema with a <Root xmlns='http://myschema/myschema.xsd'> it throws an
XmlSchemaValida tionException - which is good.

However, if I, or the client of my service omits the xmlns tag then
there is no error thrown. If I add an ValidationEvent Handler I find
that the difference is that when the schema is specified it is an
XmlSeverityType .Error where as if no xmlns is given it is only an
XmlSeverityType .Warning.

Why? Why? Why? Why? Why? The XML document is wrong, it doesn't
validate. I have told it to validate against the schema the idea being
that if my client(s) send it incorrectly it fails. Yet they can now
get around the validation by not declaring the schema in the XML
document. To me this is stupid, stupid, stupid. Surely one of the
main ideas of the schema is that we do not wholly trust the originator
of the XML to be correct so we wish to check?

Basically - is there anyway around this?

[Zafar Abbas]

If the root of the XML document can not be strictly validated, because of
either

1. lack of element declaration of that item
2. lack of type present based on the xsi:type attribute on that element.

then LAX validation is performed as if the type of that element is
xs:anyType. You will get a validation warning in such cases, not errors. You
should filter for Warnings as well as Errors while accepting these XML
documents.

You can look up the XSD spec which specifies this behavior at:
http://www.w3.org/TR/2004/PER-xmlsch...cvc-assess-elt

Thanks,
Zafar

<pe********@gma il.com> wrote in message
news:11******** *************@g 49g2000cwa.goog legroups.com...

I have an XML schema and I am trying to validate any XML document sent
against it.

Here's some of the code:
XmlReaderSettin gs xmlReaderSettin gs = new
XmlReaderSettin gs();
xmlReaderSettin gs.Schemas.Add( @"http://myschema/myschema.xsd",
"myschema.xsd") ;
xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationEv entHandler += new
ValidationEvent Handler(Validat ionEvent);

xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationTy pe = ValidationType. Schema;

xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationFl ags =
xmlReaderSettin gs.ValidationFl ags |

XmlSchemaValida tionFlags.Repor tValidationWarn ings;
XmlReader xmlReader = XmlReader.Creat e(myXmlDocument ,
xmlReaderSettin gs);

while(xmlReader .Read());

Now, my problem is, if I specify an XML document which breaks the
schema with a <Root xmlns='http://myschema/myschema.xsd'> it throws an
XmlSchemaValida tionException - which is good.

However, if I, or the client of my service omits the xmlns tag then
there is no error thrown. If I add an ValidationEvent Handler I find
that the difference is that when the schema is specified it is an
XmlSeverityType .Error where as if no xmlns is given it is only an
XmlSeverityType .Warning.

Why? Why? Why? Why? Why? The XML document is wrong, it doesn't
validate. I have told it to validate against the schema the idea being
that if my client(s) send it incorrectly it fails. Yet they can now
get around the validation by not declaring the schema in the XML
document. To me this is stupid, stupid, stupid. Surely one of the
main ideas of the schema is that we do not wholly trust the originator
of the XML to be correct so we wish to check?

Basically - is there anyway around this?