Error message explained

[mdh]

I understand *why* this produces an error and how to correct it, (add
parentheses) but the error itself is a bit eclectic? As I am sure this
will arise again, could anyone throw some logic at it.

int main (int argc, const char * argv[]) {
struct point {
int x;
int y;
};

struct point *pp;
struct point origin;
pp= &origin;

origin = makepoint(23, 67);

printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); /*error: request for member 'y'
in something not a structure or union*/

}

Thanks in advance

[vippstar]

On Aug 23, 6:41 pm, mdh <m...@comcast.n etwrote:

I understand *why* this produces an error and how to correct it, (add
parentheses) but the error itself is a bit eclectic? As I am sure this
will arise again, could anyone throw some logic at it.

int main (int argc, const char * argv[]) {

struct point {
int x;
int y;

};

struct point *pp;
struct point origin;
pp= &origin;

origin = makepoint(23, 67);

printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); /*error: request for member 'y'
in something not a structure or union*/

}

See operator precedence.
.. bounds tigher than *

*pp.y means *(pp.y)

pp is a pointer, . requires structure or union

[Joe Wright]

mdh wrote:

I understand *why* this produces an error and how to correct it, (add
parentheses) but the error itself is a bit eclectic? As I am sure this
will arise again, could anyone throw some logic at it.

int main (int argc, const char * argv[]) {
struct point {
int x;
int y;
};

struct point *pp;
struct point origin;
pp= &origin;

origin = makepoint(23, 67);

printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); /*error: request for member 'y'
in something not a structure or union*/

}

Thanks in advance

It's a snytax error. As written *pp.y assumes pp a structure and y a
pointer to int. None of that is true.

--
Joe Wright
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler."
--- Albert Einstein ---

[mdh]

On Aug 23, 8:57*am, Joe Wright <joewwri...@com cast.netwrote:

mdh wrote:

I understand *why* this produces an error and how to correct it,

snip

int main (int argc, const char * argv[]) {

struct point {
* *int x;
* *int y;
};

* *struct point *pp;
* *struct point origin;
* *pp= &origin;

>

* *printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); */*error: request for member 'y'
in something not a structure or union*/

>
It's a snytax error. As written *pp.y assumes pp a structure and y a
pointer to int. None of that is true.

Thanks Joe...yes that makes sense. One more eclectism falls :-)

[mdh]

On Aug 23, 8:57*am, vipps...@gmail. com wrote:

>
pp is a pointer, . requires structure or union

thanks

[Harald van =?UTF-8?b?RMSzaw==?=]

On Sat, 23 Aug 2008 11:57:15 -0400, Joe Wright wrote:

mdh wrote:

> struct point *pp;
[...]
printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); /*error: request for member

'y'

>in something not a structure or union*/

It's a snytax error.

No, it's not, unless snytax is an intentional misspelling that I am not
familiar with. *pp.y is syntactically valid, but semantically invalid.

[gw7rib]

On 23 Aug, 16:41, mdh <m...@comcast.n etwrote:

I understand *why* this produces an error and how to correct it, (add
parentheses) but the error itself is a bit eclectic? As I am sure this
will arise again, could anyone throw some logic at it.

int main (int argc, const char * argv[]) {

struct point {
* * * * int x;
* * * * int y;

};

* * * * struct point *pp;
* * * * struct point origin;
* * * * pp= &origin;

* * * * origin = makepoint(23, 67);

* * * * printf("%d, %d\n", (*pp).x, *pp.y); */*error: request for member 'y'
in something not a structure or union*/

}

Thanks in advance

Erm, it seems to make perfect sense to me. The '.' means you are
accessing a member of a struct or union, so pp.y means "access the
member called 'y' of the struct or union pp". Which is wrong, beacause
pp is not a struct or union - it is a pointer to a struct. So pp isn't
a struct or a union, and it doesn't have members. So it's an error to
access member 'y' of it.