rewriting typedef to define

[wongjoekmeu]

I need to rewrite some typedef to #define.

For instance I rewrote

typedef void* handle
to
#define handle void*

But I saw for instance another typedef in my code which I don't
understand, which is

typedef const char* const* attrListPtr;

First I don't really understand this typedef and then I was wondering
how this should be rewritten using #define

I also have another typedef which I do understand. It is used for
function aliasing. But I was wondering how and if it is possible in
such a case also to replace the typedef by using #define.

For instance how would you rewrite:

typedef double (*Addition)(dou ble value1, double value2);

??

Many thanks in advance,

rr

[Alf P. Steinbach]

* wo*********@yah oo.com:

I need to rewrite some typedef to #define.

Most probably you don't.

I have never needed that.

You should avoid macros (except where really needed such as header guards)
because they don't respect scopes and namespaces and have counter-intuitive effects.

For instance I rewrote

typedef void* handle

And most probably you don't need void* pointers.

Those are for experienced folks doing low-level things.

You, on the other hand, are not experienced (otherwise you wouldn't have asked),
and presumably you're not doing low-level things either.

to
#define handle void*

Thus breaking a lot of code where the word "handle" occurs.

But I saw for instance another typedef in my code which I don't
understand, which is

typedef const char* const* attrListPtr;

You have written ("my code") something you don't understand.

Try to write only things you understand.

Of course when using copy-and-modify techqnique to make interesting or useful
programs, you cannot totally avoid including code you don't yet understand.

First I don't really understand this typedef and then I was wondering
how this should be rewritten using #define

Don't.

I also have another typedef which I do understand. It is used for
function aliasing. But I was wondering how and if it is possible in
such a case also to replace the typedef by using #define.

Don't.

For instance how would you rewrite:

typedef double (*Addition)(dou ble value1, double value2);

One wouldn't.
Cheers, & hth.,

- Alf

[kepeng]

On 4ÔÂ13ÈÕ, ÉÏÎç12ʱ36·Ö, "wongjoek...@ya hoo.com" <wongjoek...@ya hoo.com>
wrote:

I need to rewrite some typedef to #define.

For instance I rewrote

typedef void* handle
to
#define handle void*

This should cause problem.
You'd better not do like this.

>
But I saw for instance another typedef in my code which I don't
understand, which is

typedef const char* const* attrListPtr;

attrListPtr is a pointer, point to a const pointer variable, which
point to a const char (array).
You can understand it like this:
typedef const char* (const(* attrListPtr));
and I think the following typedef should be better:
typedef const char* (*attrListPtr) const;

>
First I don't really understand this typedef and then I was wondering
how this should be rewritten using #define

I also have another typedef which I do understand. It is used for
function aliasing. But I was wondering how and if it is possible in
such a case also to replace the typedef by using #define.

For instance how would you rewrite:

typedef double (*Addition)(dou ble value1, double value2);

Don't use #define with this.
And I don't know how to do it.

>
??

Many thanks in advance,

rr

[Ian Collins]

wo*********@yah oo.com wrote:

I need to rewrite some typedef to #define.

Why?

--
Ian Collins.

[Juha Nieminen]

wo*********@yah oo.com wrote:

I also have another typedef which I do understand. It is used for
function aliasing. But I was wondering how and if it is possible in
such a case also to replace the typedef by using #define.

It's not possible. I can't understand why you would want to.

[James Kanze]

On 12 avr, 18:36, "wongjoek...@ya hoo.com" <wongjoek...@ya hoo.com>
wrote:

I need to rewrite some typedef to #define.

To start with, no you don't. If anything, you should be going
in the other direction.

For instance I rewrote

typedef void* handle
to
#define handle void*

Which isn't at all the same thing, consider:

const handle whatever ;

But I saw for instance another typedef in my code which I
don't understand, which is

typedef const char* const* attrListPtr;

First I don't really understand this typedef and then I was
wondering how this should be rewritten using #define

It can't be. In general, nothing involving pointers and arrays
can be.

(Well, strictly speaking:

typedef char const* const* hiddenAttrListP tr ;
#define attrListPtr hiddenAttrListP tr

will work.)

I also have another typedef which I do understand. It is used
for function aliasing. But I was wondering how and if it is
possible in such a case also to replace the typedef by using
#define.

For instance how would you rewrite:

typedef double (*Addition)(dou ble value1, double value2);

??

As above. But as I said, you should be going the other way.
#define doesn't work as a typedef, and creates unnecessary
confusion.

--
James Kanze (GABI Software) email:ja******* **@gmail.com
Conseils en informatique orientée objet/
Beratung in objektorientier ter Datenverarbeitu ng
9 place Sémard, 78210 St.-Cyr-l'École, France, [phone]

[James Kanze]

On 12 avr, 19:01, "Alf P. Steinbach" <[e-mail] wrote:

* wongjoek...@yah oo.com:

[...]

But I saw for instance another typedef in my code which I don't
understand, which is

typedef const char* const* attrListPtr;

You have written ("my code") something you don't understand.

For many of us, "my code" means some horrible junk that we got
pushed off on us because no one else could understand it:-). I
didn't write it, anymore than I made "my car".

--
James Kanze (GABI Software) email:ja******* **@gmail.com
Conseils en informatique orientée objet/
Beratung in objektorientier ter Datenverarbeitu ng
9 place Sémard, 78210 St.-Cyr-l'École, France, [phone]