Passing function as argument

[steven_orocos]

Hi,

I'm tryin to pass a funtion as an argument in another funtion.

This code works
----------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void test1(int a){cout<<"1";}
void test2(int a){cout<<"2";}
void test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3(test1);
}
--------------------------------
But when I put the cide in a class, it won't work anymore.
-------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void MyClass::test1( int a){cout<<"1";}
void MyClass::test2( int a){cout<<"2";}
void MyClass::test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void MyClass::test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3((func)tes t1);
}
-----------------------
Gives me the error
--------------
error: argument of type 'void (MyClass::)(int )' does not match
'void (*)(int)'
error: invalid use of member (did you forget the '&' ?)
--------------------

I've tried several things, like
test3(&test1);
or
typedef void (MyClass::*func )(int);
But i can't find the solution.
Also the net gives me several different solution, but none work..

[Ondra Holub]

st***********@v anderbeke.be napsal:

Hi,

I'm tryin to pass a funtion as an argument in another funtion.

This code works
----------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void test1(int a){cout<<"1";}
void test2(int a){cout<<"2";}
void test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3(test1);
}
--------------------------------
But when I put the cide in a class, it won't work anymore.
-------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void MyClass::test1( int a){cout<<"1";}
void MyClass::test2( int a){cout<<"2";}
void MyClass::test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void MyClass::test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3((func)tes t1);
}
-----------------------
Gives me the error
--------------
error: argument of type 'void (MyClass::)(int )' does not match
'void (*)(int)'
error: invalid use of member (did you forget the '&' ?)
--------------------

I've tried several things, like
test3(&test1);
or
typedef void (MyClass::*func )(int);
But i can't find the solution.
Also the net gives me several different solution, but none work..

You are trying to pass pointer to member of class as parameter. It is
something different, than pointer to ordinary function. But you can
still pass pointer to static member function - it works same way as
ordinary function, because it does not need 'this' value for invocation.

[Roland Pibinger]

On 27 Nov 2006 04:47:26 -0800, steven_orocos wrote:

>I'm tryin to pass a funtion as an argument in another funtion.
But when I put the cide in a class, it won't work anymore.
Also the net gives me several different solution, but none work..

Try this: http://www.newty.de/fpt/index.html

Good luck,
Roland Pibinger

[Jacek Dziedzic]

st***********@v anderbeke.be wrote:

Hi,

I'm tryin to pass a funtion as an argument in another funtion.

This code works
----------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void test1(int a){cout<<"1";}
void test2(int a){cout<<"2";}
void test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3(test1);
}
--------------------------------
But when I put the cide in a class, it won't work anymore.
-------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

void MyClass::test1( int a){cout<<"1";}
void MyClass::test2( int a){cout<<"2";}
void MyClass::test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {
(fp)(5);
}
void MyClass::test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;
test3((func)tes t1);
}
-----------------------
Gives me the error
--------------
error: argument of type 'void (MyClass::)(int )' does not match
'void (*)(int)'
error: invalid use of member (did you forget the '&' ?)
--------------------

I've tried several things, like
test3(&test1);
or
typedef void (MyClass::*func )(int);
But i can't find the solution.
Also the net gives me several different solution, but none work..

Pointers to members differ from pointers to ordinary functions
(and one cannot be cast to another), because member functions take
an extra "hidden" 'this' argument.

HTH,
- J.

[steven_orocos]

Roland Pibinger schreef:

Try this: http://www.newty.de/fpt/index.html

I had allready found that link
using this code
test3(*this.*te st1);
I get error: '((MyClass*)thi s)->MyClass::test1 ' cannot be used as a
member pointer, since it is of type '<unknown type>'
And this
test3((void(*)( int))*this.*tes t1);
gives me
error: invalid cast from type 'MyClass' to type 'void (*)(int)'

[David Harmon]

On 27 Nov 2006 04:47:26 -0800 in comp.lang.c++,
st***********@v anderbeke.be wrote,

>--------------------------------
But when I put the cide in a class, it won't work anymore.
-------------------------------
typedef void (*func)(int);

typedef void (MyClass::*func )(int);

>void MyClass::test1( int a){cout<<"1";}
void MyClass::test2( int a){cout<<"2";}
void MyClass::test3 (void (*fp) (int)) {

void MyClass::test3 (func fp) {

> (fp)(5);

(this->*fp)(5);

>}
void MyClass::test() {
func pf;
pf = test1;

pf = &test1;

> test3((func)tes t1);

test3(&test1);

This issue is covered in Marshall Cline's C++ FAQ. See the section
"[33.5] How can I avoid syntax errors when calling a member function
using a pointer-to-member-function? " but ignore his #define. It is
always good to check the FAQ before posting. You can get the FAQ at:
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lite/