object architecture,

[Vincent RICHOMME]

Hi,

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

class IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList ) {}
};
 
 
// EPropCtrl : Windows control (MFC) that looks like a ListBox
class EPropCtrl
{
public:
SetPropPointer( IPropertyHost* pHost);
};
 

Pratically when I want to display/modify properties of a simple class
defined like this :

class Simple
{
protected:
int iValue;
};
 

I just need to create a new class deriving from Simple Class AND from
IPropertyHost like this :

class SimpleProp : public Simple,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void     GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{
PropList.AddPropInt(this,_T("iValue"),&iValue, false);
}
 
 
 
IPropertyHost*     GetPropPointer() { return this; }
protected:
int iValue;
};
 

and after to update my control by doing :

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl; // Graphical window to display/edit propertis
SimpleProp simpleProp; //Objet SimpleProp
objPropCtrl.Set PropPointer( simpleProp.GetP ropPointer() );
// --------------- SO FAR EVERYTHING IS OK --------------------------

Now let's consider two objects that wrapps C structures like this :

typedef struct tagStructB
{
int        iSizeB;
char*      szTextB;
} StructB;
 
typedef struct tagStructA
{
int        iSizeA;
char*      szTextA;
 
StructB sStructB;
} StructA;
 
class B
{
public:
B(structB& refStructB) { m_refStructB = refStructB ;}
int        GetSize() {return m_StructB.iSizeB;}
char*    GetText() {return m_StructB.szTextB;}
 
protected:
structB& m_refStructB;
};
 
 
class A
{
public:
A();
int        GetSize() {return m_StructA.iSizeA;}
char*    GetText() {return m_StructA.szTextA;}
B&        GetB() { return m_B; }
 
 
protected:
structA m_StructA;
B        m_B;
};
 
Example of use :
 
A m_a;
int iSizeA = m_A.GetSize();
m_A.GetB().GetSize();
 

If I am doing the same as the simple example I would do somthing like :

class BProp: public B,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{
PropList.AddPro pInt(this,_T("i SizeB"),&m_refS tructB.iSizeB, false);
PropList.AddPro pString(this,_T ("szTextB"),&m_ refStructB.szTe xtB, false);

}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

class AProp: public A,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{

PropList.AddPro pInt(this,_T("i SizeA"),&m__Str uctA.iSizeA, false);
PropList.AddPro pString(this,_T ("szTextA"),&m_ _StructA.szText A, false);
m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ); // <----- CANNOT WORK
}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl;
AProp objAProp;

objPropCtrl.Set PropPointer( objAProp.GetPro pPointer() );

// PROBLEM : I CANNOT call m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ) to display B
properties from AProp since Aprop has only a B and not a BProp.
HOw should I change my objets to display my properties ??????????????

[red floyd]

Vincent RICHOMME wrote:

Hi,

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

[long OT post redacted]

You would do better in a newsgroup with MFC or Windows in its name.

See FAQ 5.9 : http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit...t.html#faq-5.9

[Victor Bazarov]

Vincent RICHOMME wrote:

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

 class IPropertyHost
 {
 public:
     virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList ) {}
 };


 // EPropCtrl : Windows control (MFC) that looks like a ListBox
 class EPropCtrl
 {
     public:
     SetPropPointer( IPropertyHost* pHost);
 };
 

Pratically when I want to display/modify properties of a simple class
defined like this :

 class Simple
 {
 protected:
     int iValue;
 };
 

I just need to create a new class deriving from Simple Class AND from
IPropertyHost like this :

 class SimpleProp : public Simple,
                    public IPropertyHost
 {
 public:
     virtual void     GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
     {
         PropList.AddPropInt(this,_T("iValue"),&iValue, false);
     }



     IPropertyHost*     GetPropPointer() { return this; }
 protected:
     int iValue;
 };
 

and after to update my control by doing :

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl; // Graphical window to display/edit propertis
SimpleProp simpleProp; //Objet SimpleProp
objPropCtrl.Set PropPointer( simpleProp.GetP ropPointer() );
// --------------- SO FAR EVERYTHING IS OK --------------------------

Now let's consider two objects that wrapps C structures like this :

 typedef struct tagStructB
 {
     int        iSizeB;
     char*      szTextB;
 } StructB;

 typedef struct tagStructA
 {
     int        iSizeA;
     char*      szTextA;

     StructB sStructB;
 } StructA;

 class B
 {
 public:
     B(structB& refStructB) { m_refStructB = refStructB ;}
     int        GetSize() {return m_StructB.iSizeB;}
     char*    GetText() {return m_StructB.szTextB;}

 protected:
     structB& m_refStructB;
 };


 class A
 {
 public:
     A();
     int        GetSize() {return m_StructA.iSizeA;}
     char*    GetText() {return m_StructA.szTextA;}
     B&        GetB() { return m_B; }


 protected:
     structA m_StructA;
     B        m_B;
 };

 Example of use :

 A m_a;
 int iSizeA = m_A.GetSize();
 m_A.GetB().GetSize();
 

If I am doing the same as the simple example I would do somthing like
:
class BProp: public B,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{
PropList.AddPro pInt(this,_T("i SizeB"),&m_refS tructB.iSizeB, false);
PropList.AddPro pString(this,_T ("szTextB"),&m_ refStructB.szTe xtB,
false);
}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

class AProp: public A,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{

PropList.AddPro pInt(this,_T("i SizeA"),&m__Str uctA.iSizeA, false);
PropList.AddPro pString(this,_T ("szTextA"),&m_ _StructA.szText A, false);
m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ); // <----- CANNOT WORK
}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl;
AProp objAProp;

objPropCtrl.Set PropPointer( objAProp.GetPro pPointer() );

// PROBLEM : I CANNOT call m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ) to display B
properties from AProp since Aprop has only a B and not a BProp.
HOw should I change my objets to display my properties ??????????????

You can make your 'AProp' to keep a 'BProp' instead...

You could change the whole scheme of creating/displaying of properties
to using "visitors" instead of deriving "property-ized" objects from
"regular" ones.

V
--
Please remove capital 'A's when replying by e-mail
I do not respond to top-posted replies, please don't ask

[Victor Bazarov]

red floyd wrote:

Vincent RICHOMME wrote:

Hi,

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

[long OT post redacted]

You would do better in a newsgroup with MFC or Windows in its name.

See FAQ 5.9 :
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit...t.html#faq-5.9

Not really, he wouldn't. The question is not about MFC per se.
Did you bother to read it to the end?

V
--
Please remove capital 'A's when replying by e-mail
I do not respond to top-posted replies, please don't ask

[Vincent RICHOMME]

Victor Bazarov wrote:
Could You tell me more about your suggestion on visitors ?
Just give me an example starting from what I give. I will try to understand.

thanks

Vincent RICHOMME wrote:

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

class IPropertyHost
{
public:
    virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList ) {}
};


// EPropCtrl : Windows control (MFC) that looks like a ListBox
class EPropCtrl
{
    public:
    SetPropPointer( IPropertyHost* pHost);
};

Pratically when I want to display/modify properties of a simple class
defined like this :

class Simple
{
protected:
    int iValue;
};

I just need to create a new class deriving from Simple Class AND from
IPropertyHo st like this :

class SimpleProp : public Simple,
                   public IPropertyHost
{
public:
    virtual void     GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
    {
        PropList.AddPropInt(this,_T("iValue"),&iValue, false);
    }



    IPropertyHost*     GetPropPointer() { return this; }
protected:
    int iValue;
};

and after to update my control by doing :

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl; // Graphical window to display/edit propertis
SimpleProp simpleProp; //Objet SimpleProp
objPropCtrl.S etPropPointer( simpleProp.GetP ropPointer() );
// --------------- SO FAR EVERYTHING IS OK --------------------------

Now let's consider two objects that wrapps C structures like this :

typedef struct tagStructB
{
    int        iSizeB;
    char*      szTextB;
} StructB;

typedef struct tagStructA
{
    int        iSizeA;
    char*      szTextA;

    StructB sStructB;
} StructA;

class B
{
public:
    B(structB& refStructB) { m_refStructB = refStructB ;}
    int        GetSize() {return m_StructB.iSizeB;}
    char*    GetText() {return m_StructB.szTextB;}

protected:
    structB& m_refStructB;
};


class A
{
public:
    A();
    int        GetSize() {return m_StructA.iSizeA;}
    char*    GetText() {return m_StructA.szTextA;}
    B&        GetB() { return m_B; }


protected:
    structA m_StructA;
    B        m_B;
};

Example of use :

A m_a;
int iSizeA = m_A.GetSize();
m_A.GetB().GetSize();

If I am doing the same as the simple example I would do somthing like
:
class BProp: public B,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{
PropList.AddP ropInt(this,_T( "iSizeB"),&m_re fStructB.iSizeB , false);
PropList.AddP ropString(this, _T("szTextB"),& m_refStructB.sz TextB,
false);
}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

class AProp: public A,
public IPropertyHost
{
public:
virtual void GetProperties( EPropList& PropList )
{

PropList.AddP ropInt(this,_T( "iSizeA"),&m__S tructA.iSizeA, false);
PropList.AddP ropString(this, _T("szTextA"),& m__StructA.szTe xtA, false);
m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ); // <----- CANNOT WORK
}
IPropertyHost* GetPropPointer( ) { return this; }
};

EPropCtrl objPropCtrl;
AProp objAProp;

objPropCtrl.S etPropPointer( objAProp.GetPro pPointer() );

// PROBLEM : I CANNOT call m_B.GetProperti es( PropList ) to display B
properties from AProp since Aprop has only a B and not a BProp.
HOw should I change my objets to display my properties ??????????????

You can make your 'AProp' to keep a 'BProp' instead...

You could change the whole scheme of creating/displaying of properties
to using "visitors" instead of deriving "property-ized" objects from
"regular" ones.

V

[red floyd]

Victor Bazarov wrote:

red floyd wrote:

Vincent RICHOMME wrote:

Hi,

My goal is to display in a graphical application properties of my
objects. To do that I am using on windows a graphical control (MFC)
called EPropCtrl with the following definition :

[long OT post redacted]

You would do better in a newsgroup with MFC or Windows in its name.

See FAQ 5.9 :
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit...t.html#faq-5.9

Not really, he wouldn't. The question is not about MFC per se.
Did you bother to read it to the end?

Sorry, I saw all this properties stuff, and IThis, IThat and
IAmAnInterface stuff and pretty much figured it was. My apologies to
the OP.