Undo/Redo Pattern

[Christian H]

Hello,

I've tried to find information about how to implement an Undo/Redo pattern.
This article describes such a pattern:
http://www.codeproject.com/csharp/PcObjectUndo.asp , but is a little bit to
narrow, since it only can handle 1 object, and since it only works on
properties.

What if you , in an application, have more than 1 object , and you want to
use undo/redo on them?
What if you'd like it to work on methods as well as properties?

If there is a better pattern than the one in the link, that will let me do
this, please let me know.
Christian H.

[Jussi Jumppanen]

Christian H wrote:

I've tried to find information about how to implement an
Undo/Redo pattern.
I implement undo/redo using two stacks. I used a "do" and an
"undo" stack.

When a change is made it goes onto the "do" stack. To undo the
change it is just poped of the "do" stack and pushed onto the
"undo" stack.

What gets pushed and poped are primitive operations encapsulated
in an object. These objects hold all the information required to
do or undo themselves.

I would assume this is quite a common apprach.
What if you , in an application, have more than 1 object,
and you want to use undo/redo on them?
I have about 15 types of objects to handle all the different
situations but they all share a common base class so they
can share a common stack.
If there is a better pattern than the one in the link,
that will let me do this, please let me know.

When I first developed my undo/redo method it took quite
some time to get it working correctly. I started by just
trying to implement a few simple case and then slowly
adding new cases. After a few false starts it all fell
into place quite nicely :)

Jussi Jumppanen
Author of: Zeus for Windows (New version 3.93 out now)
"The C/C++, Cobol, Java, HTML, Python, PHP, Perl programmer's editor"
Home Page: http://www.zeusedit.com

[Ignacio Machin \( .NET/ C# MVP \)]

Hi,

Take a look at the Command pattern.
http://www.dofactory.com/Patterns/PatternCommand.aspx

in the above link they do a calculator with an undo/redo capability.

Cheers,

--
Ignacio Machin,
ignacio.machin AT dot.state.fl.us
Florida Department Of Transportation

"Christian H" <[e-mail]> wrote in message
news:2G******** **********@news 4.e.nsc.no...

Hello,

I've tried to find information about how to implement an Undo/Redo
pattern.
This article describes such a pattern:
http://www.codeproject.com/csharp/PcObjectUndo.asp , but is a little bit
to narrow, since it only can handle 1 object, and since it only works on
properties.

What if you , in an application, have more than 1 object , and you want to
use undo/redo on them?
What if you'd like it to work on methods as well as properties?

If there is a better pattern than the one in the link, that will let me
do this, please let me know.
Christian H.