Component Creation

[Roshawn Dawson]

Hi All,

I am creating a component library and I have a function that contains
optional parameters. Here's the skeleton code for the function:

Public Function SearchBook(ByVal page as String, Optional ByVal keyword
As String = Nothing, Optional ByVal categoryID As String = Nothing) As Book

' implementation code omitted

End Function

My gripe is with the optional parameters. Specifically, this function
can be used three ways:

1. use take the page and keyword params (omitting the catagoryID param)
2. use the page and categoryID params (omitting the keyword param)
3. use all three params.

Are there any penalties for ignoring only one of the optional
parameters? Must they both be used (because I don't feel like writing
overloaded functions)if one of them is used? Is the order in which
they're placed an issue?

Thanks,
Roshawn

[Larry Serflaten]

"Roshawn Dawson" <ud****@bellsouth.net> wrote

My gripe is with the optional parameters. Specifically, this function
can be used three ways:

1. use take the page and keyword params (omitting the catagoryID param)
2. use the page and categoryID params (omitting the keyword param)
3. use all three params.

Are there any penalties for ignoring only one of the optional
parameters? Must they both be used (because I don't feel like writing
overloaded functions)if one of them is used? Is the order in which
they're placed an issue?

I don't have a link to point to, but my understanding was that even though
you give it optional parameters, the compiler treats it as if all of them are
required. For code that does not use one of the optional parameters, the
compiler will simply add the default value in for the missing parameter.

Is the order an issue? I would think you should try to put the most
common in front, (to making coding easier) but when all are strings,
what could it matter?

Passing in Page as a string seems odd, shouldn't that be a number?

LFS

[Larry Serflaten]

"Roshawn Dawson" <ud****@bellsouth.net> wrote

My gripe is with the optional parameters. Specifically, this function
can be used three ways:

1. use take the page and keyword params (omitting the catagoryID param)
2. use the page and categoryID params (omitting the keyword param)
3. use all three params.

Are there any penalties for ignoring only one of the optional
parameters? Must they both be used (because I don't feel like writing
overloaded functions)if one of them is used? Is the order in which
they're placed an issue?

I don't have a link to point to, but my understanding was that even though
you give it optional parameters, the compiler treats it as if all of them are
required. For code that does not use one of the optional parameters, the
compiler will simply add the default value in for the missing parameter.

Is the order an issue? I would think you should try to put the most
common in front, (to making coding easier) but when all are strings,
what could it matter?

Passing in Page as a string seems odd, shouldn't that be a number?

LFS

[Darious Snell]

Look into the "overloads" statement.
"Roshawn Dawson" <ud****@bellsouth.net> wrote in message
news:%2****************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

Hi All,

I am creating a component library and I have a function that contains
optional parameters. Here's the skeleton code for the function:

Public Function SearchBook(ByVal page as String, Optional ByVal keyword
As String = Nothing, Optional ByVal categoryID As String = Nothing) As Book

' implementation code omitted

End Function

My gripe is with the optional parameters. Specifically, this function
can be used three ways:

1. use take the page and keyword params (omitting the catagoryID param)
2. use the page and categoryID params (omitting the keyword param)
3. use all three params.

Are there any penalties for ignoring only one of the optional
parameters? Must they both be used (because I don't feel like writing
overloaded functions)if one of them is used? Is the order in which
they're placed an issue?

Thanks,
Roshawn

[Darious Snell]

Look into the "overloads" statement.
"Roshawn Dawson" <ud****@bellsouth.net> wrote in message
news:%2****************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

Hi All,

I am creating a component library and I have a function that contains
optional parameters. Here's the skeleton code for the function:

Public Function SearchBook(ByVal page as String, Optional ByVal keyword
As String = Nothing, Optional ByVal categoryID As String = Nothing) As Book

' implementation code omitted

End Function

My gripe is with the optional parameters. Specifically, this function
can be used three ways:

1. use take the page and keyword params (omitting the catagoryID param)
2. use the page and categoryID params (omitting the keyword param)
3. use all three params.

Are there any penalties for ignoring only one of the optional
parameters? Must they both be used (because I don't feel like writing
overloaded functions)if one of them is used? Is the order in which
they're placed an issue?

Thanks,
Roshawn