472,353 Members | 1,236 Online
Bytes | Software Development & Data Engineering Community
+ Post

Home Posts Topics Members FAQ

Join Bytes to post your question to a community of 472,353 software developers and data experts.

Standard Threads vs Weightless Threads

Recently I read Charming Python: Implementing Weightless Threads
(http://www-128.ibm.com/developerwork.../l-pythrd.html) by
David D.

I'm not an authority on threading architectures so I'd like to ask the
following:

1)What is the difference (in terms of performance, scalability,[insert
relevant metric here]) between microthreads and "system" threads?

2)If microthreads really are superior then why aren't they the standard
Python implementation (or at least within the standard library)? (where
my assumption is that they are not the standard implementation and are
not contained within the standard library).

ps. I fear that my questions and assumptions about threading may be
rather naive. If they are, it's because I haven't yet done any
significant research.

Aug 1 '05 #1
2 1451
yoda wrote:
1)What is the difference (in terms of performance, scalability,[insert
relevant metric here]) between microthreads and "system" threads?
System-level threads are relatively heavyweight. They come with a full
call stack, and they take up some level of kernel resources [generally
less than a process]. In exchange, they're scheduled by the OS, with
the primary benefit (on uniprocessor systems) that if one thread
executes a blocking task (like IO writes) another thread will receive
CPU attention.

The primary disadvantage is that they're scheduled by the CPU. This
leads to the concurrency nightmare, where the developer needs to keep
track of what blocks of code (and data) need locks to prevent deadlock
and race conditions.

2)If microthreads really are superior then why aren't they the standard
Python implementation (or at least within the standard library)? (where
my assumption is that they are not the standard implementation and are
not contained within the standard library).


Microthreads are very different; they're entirely internal to the Python
process, and they're not seen at all by the operating system.
Scheduling is done explicitly by the microthread implementation --
multitasking is not preemptive, as with system threads.

They're not in the standard library because implementing microthreads
has thus far required a very large rewrite of the CPython architecture
-- see Stackless Python.
Aug 1 '05 #2
Christopher Subich <sp****************@block.subich.spam.com> writes:
the primary benefit (on uniprocessor systems) that if one thread
executes a blocking task (like IO writes) another thread will receive
CPU attention.
On multiprocessor systems, of course, the benefit is that threads can
run on separate CPUs. This could possibly be addressed by transparently
running one OS thread for each CPU, each containing a set of light
weight threads, and I hear people are thinking about that for Erlang
(light weight processes language extravaganza).

In the meanwhile, you can of course solve this by running two separate
instances of your program that communicates with each other somehow.

Another benefit is that you can have more threads than the limit the OS
imposes on you, and they can also be made quite a bit less memory
consuming. Some language implementations manages to deal with hundreds
of thousands, and in some cases even millions, of threads this way.
They're not in the standard library because implementing microthreads
has thus far required a very large rewrite of the CPython architecture
-- see Stackless Python.


Ruby's built-in threading also work something like this (if I understand
Stackless Python correctly).

(http://www.rubycentral.com/book/tut_threads.html)

Personally, though, I think treating treating light weight threads as
separate processes (which can only pass messages in between each other,
but do not share scope in any way), like Erlang, seems to make dealing
with massive concurrency easier.

--
Björn Lindström <bk**@stp.lingfil.uu.se>
Student of computational linguistics, Uppsala University, Sweden
Aug 1 '05 #3

This thread has been closed and replies have been disabled. Please start a new discussion.

Similar topics

20
by: skoco | last post by:
Hello! Do you know when will be the new standard for c++ approved? And WHAT will be inside? Hope there will be some thread and synchro classes,...
85
by: fermineutron | last post by:
Some compilers support __asm{ } statement which allows integration of C and raw assembly code. A while back I asked a question about such syntax...
22
by: Chris Thomasson | last post by:
I am thinking about using this technique for all the "local" memory pools in a paticular multi-threaded allocator algorithm I invented. Some more...
4
by: dustin | last post by:
I've been hacking away on this PEP for a while, and there has been some related discussion on python-dev that went into the PEP: ...
126
by: Dann Corbit | last post by:
Rather than create a new way of doing things: http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2008/n2497.html why not just pick up ACE into the...
1
by: Kemmylinns12 | last post by:
Blockchain technology has emerged as a transformative force in the business world, offering unprecedented opportunities for innovation and...
0
by: Naresh1 | last post by:
What is WebLogic Admin Training? WebLogic Admin Training is a specialized program designed to equip individuals with the skills and knowledge...
0
by: antdb | last post by:
Ⅰ. Advantage of AntDB: hyper-convergence + streaming processing engine In the overall architecture, a new "hyper-convergence" concept was...
0
by: AndyPSV | last post by:
HOW CAN I CREATE AN AI with an .executable file that would suck all files in the folder and on my computerHOW CAN I CREATE AN AI with an .executable...
0
by: Arjunsri | last post by:
I have a Redshift database that I need to use as an import data source. I have configured the DSN connection using the server, port, database, and...
0
by: Matthew3360 | last post by:
Hi, I have been trying to connect to a local host using php curl. But I am finding it hard to do this. I am doing the curl get request from my web...
0
by: Carina712 | last post by:
Setting background colors for Excel documents can help to improve the visual appeal of the document and make it easier to read and understand....
0
BLUEPANDA
by: BLUEPANDA | last post by:
At BluePanda Dev, we're passionate about building high-quality software and sharing our knowledge with the community. That's why we've created a SaaS...
0
by: Rahul1995seven | last post by:
Introduction: In the realm of programming languages, Python has emerged as a powerhouse. With its simplicity, versatility, and robustness, Python...

By using Bytes.com and it's services, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

To disable or enable advertisements and analytics tracking please visit the manage ads & tracking page.