About Macro

[Remo]

Hi All

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Thanks & Regards
Remo

[Chris McDonald]

"Remo" <re*******@gmail.com> writes:

Hi All I Have Quation About Macro's plz help why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ... why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,, plz answer if any one knows reason.

Convention.

<OT>
Or, under Unix:

sed 's/^@/#/' < program.at > program.c
</OT>

--
Chris.

[santosh]

Remo wrote:

Hi All
I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...
why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Thats simply the way the C preprocessor works. It scans the source file
for lines that begin with the '#' character and takes the rest of that
line as it's directive.

If you really want to use someother character, feel free to modify the
source of any free cpp implementation or write your custom preprocessor
as a plugin replacement, but it that case, your programs will no longer
be C programs.

[Eric Sosman]

Remo wrote:

Hi All

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

We can!

??=include <stdio.h>
??=define POUND_SIGN "Octothorpe"
int main(void) {
printf(POUND_SIGN " is unnecessary!\n");
return 0;
}

--
Eric Sosman
es*****@acm-dot-org.invalid

[Naresh]

Wow! this is strange! Is it an anomaly or a loophole?
Cant we use #define to redefine the symbol #??

Regards,

Eric Sosman wrote:

Remo wrote:

Hi All

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

We can!

??=include <stdio.h>
??=define POUND_SIGN "Octothorpe"
int main(void) {
printf(POUND_SIGN " is unnecessary!\n");
return 0;
}

--
Eric Sosman
es*****@acm-dot-org.invalid

[Chris Dollin]

Naresh wrote:

Wow! this is strange! Is it an anomaly or a loophole?
Please don't top-post.

Eric had said:

??=include <stdio.h>
??=define POUND_SIGN "Octothorpe"
int main(void) {
printf(POUND_SIGN " is unnecessary!\n");
return 0;

It's not an anomaly [1] nor is it a loophole. It's a trigraph.
Cant we use #define to redefine the symbol #??

No, we can't. #define can only define macros with names which are,
er, names.

[1] Well, you /could/ say trigraphs-as-a-whole count as an anomoly.

--
Chris "x.f(y) == f(x, y) == (x, y).f" Dollin
The shortcuts are all full of people using them.

[Richard G. Riley]

On 2006-03-27, Naresh <na**********@gmail.com> wrote:

Wow! this is strange! Is it an anomaly or a loophole?
Cant we use #define to redefine the symbol #??

http://publications.gbdirect.co.uk/c...abet_of_c.html

LOL

[Jordan Abel]

On 2006-03-27, Chris Dollin <ke**@hpl.hp.com> wrote:

Naresh wrote:

Wow! this is strange! Is it an anomaly or a loophole?

Please don't top-post.

Eric had said:

??=include <stdio.h>
??=define POUND_SIGN "Octothorpe"
int main(void) {
printf(POUND_SIGN " is unnecessary!\n");
return 0;

It's not an anomaly [1] nor is it a loophole. It's a trigraph.

Cant we use #define to redefine the symbol #??

No, we can't. #define can only define macros with names which are,
er, names.

[1] Well, you /could/ say trigraphs-as-a-whole count as an anomoly.

Digraphs are much better. %:define ...

[Keith Thompson]

"Remo" <re*******@gmail.com> writes:

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Because that's how the language syntax is defined. Why would you want
to use a different symbol?

--
Keith Thompson (The_Other_Keith) ks***@mib.org <http://www.ghoti.net/~kst>
San Diego Supercomputer Center <*> <http://users.sdsc.edu/~kst>
We must do something. This is something. Therefore, we must do this.

[August Karlstrom]

Keith Thompson wrote:

"Remo" <re*******@gmail.com> writes:

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Because that's how the language syntax is defined. Why would you want
to use a different symbol?

I think Remo's question is quite clear and I'm surprised by all strange
answers. Let me rephrase the question as I interpret it:

Is there any particular reason why the number sign was chosen as a
prefix for preprocessor directives? Tradition?
August

--
I am the "ILOVEGNU" signature virus. Just copy me to your
signature. This email was infected under the terms of the GNU
General Public License.

[Jordan Abel]

On 2006-03-28, August Karlstrom <fu********@comhem.se> wrote:

Keith Thompson wrote:

"Remo" <re*******@gmail.com> writes:

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Because that's how the language syntax is defined. Why would you want
to use a different symbol?

I think Remo's question is quite clear and I'm surprised by all strange
answers. Let me rephrase the question as I interpret it:

Is there any particular reason why the number sign was chosen as
a prefix for preprocessor directives? Tradition?

It was available. About the only symbols in ASCII that aren't used for
SOMETHING in C are $, @, and `, none of which are in the base character
set [But then, i suspect neither would #, if it weren't used.] # and
$ are a bit "safer" than @ and `, vs national variants, and maybe it was
a coin toss between them. $ is used in system-specific identifiers on
some implementations, but i think the original preprocessor use of
# came before those.

[Ben Bacarisse]

On Tue, 28 Mar 2006 03:35:07 +0000, August Karlstrom wrote:

Keith Thompson wrote:

"Remo" <re*******@gmail.com> writes:

I Have Quation About Macro's plz help

why do we have # symbol before any macro line #define STOP 0 ...

why con't we use the any other symbol like $, @,,

plz answer if any one knows reason.

Because that's how the language syntax is defined. Why would you want
to use a different symbol?

I think Remo's question is quite clear and I'm surprised by all strange
answers. Let me rephrase the question as I interpret it:

Is there any particular reason why the number sign was chosen as a
prefix for preprocessor directives? Tradition?

It is just possible that is is an echo from TRAC -- a general purpose
macro processing language designed by Mooers and Deutch in about 1966
which used # as the main macro marker IIRC. TRAC was intellectually
ingenious and very popular in the early 70s when C and its preprocessor
emerged. Only the original cpp authors can say if they had this in mind.

--
Ben.