Calling a template function from a template function

[Jeff Newman]

Hi all, I am trying to figure out what is causing the compile error in
the following example. I have two functions which are identical
(except one is templated), both trying to call a template function in
another class. The template function (func2) won't compile. I'm
hoping that I'm just missing something simple, but I can figure out
what it is.

struct A
{
template<typena me T>
void DoIt(T t)
{
t++;
}
};

struct B
{
void other()
{
func2<int>();
}

void func1()
{
A a;
int x = 0;
a.DoIt<int>(x);
}

template<typena me Y>
void func2()
{
A a;
Y x = 0;
a.DoIt<Y>(x); // FIXME: Compile error is here
}
};

The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

[tragomaskhalos]

On 28 Sep, 23:31, Jeff Newman <Jeffrey.M.New. [e-mail] te:
[snip]

The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.
Any help is greatly appreciated.

Comeau online accepts it OK - what compiler are
you using? If the answer is VC6 that's probably
your problem - search the archives of this group
for problems with this, esp w.r.t. templates.

[Ian Collins]

Jeff Newman wrote:

Hi all, I am trying to figure out what is causing the compile error in
the following example. I have two functions which are identical
(except one is templated), both trying to call a template function in
another class. The template function (func2) won't compile. I'm
hoping that I'm just missing something simple, but I can figure out
what it is.

template<typena me Y>
void func2()
{
A a;
Y x = 0;
a.DoIt<Y>(x); // FIXME: Compile error is here
}
};

The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Looks like a compiler bug.

--
Ian Collins.

[James Kanze]

On Sep 29, 12:31 am, Jeff Newman <Jeffrey.M.New. [e-mail] te:

Hi all, I am trying to figure out what is causing the compile error in
the following example. I have two functions which are identical
(except one is templated), both trying to call a template function in
another class. The template function (func2) won't compile. I'm
hoping that I'm just missing something simple, but I can figure out
what it is.

struct A
{
template<typena me T>
void DoIt(T t)
{
t++;
}
};

struct B
{
void other()
{
func2<int>();
}

void func1()
{
A a;
int x = 0;
a.DoIt<int>(x);
}

template<typena me Y>
void func2()
{
A a;
Y x = 0;
a.DoIt<Y>(x); // FIXME: Compile error is here
}
};

The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.

With what compiler? G++ (4.1.2) doesn't complain, but
explicitly specifying the template arguments to a function was
added to the standard fairly late, so it may not be supported by
older compilers. (E.g. I don't think VC++ 6.0 supports it,
although the more recent versions probably do.)

--
James Kanze (GABI Software) email:ja******* **@gmail.com
Conseils en informatique orientée objet/
Beratung in objektorientier ter Datenverarbeitu ng
9 place Sémard, 78210 St.-Cyr-l'École, France, [phone]

[Pete Becker]

On 2007-09-28 19:41:44 -0400, tragomaskhalos
<da************ *@logicacmg.com said:

On 28 Sep, 23:31, Jeff Newman <Jeffrey.M.New. [e-mail] te:
[snip]

>The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.
Any help is greatly appreciated.

Comeau online accepts it OK - what compiler are
you using? If the answer is VC6 that's probably
your problem - search the archives of this group
for problems with this, esp w.r.t. templates.

The error message sounds like one from gcc. Search the archives of this
group for problems with this, esp w.r.t. templates.

--
Pete
Roundhouse Consulting, Ltd. (www.versatilecoding.com) Author of "The
Standard C++ Library Extensions: a Tutorial and Reference
(www.petebecker.com/tr1book)

[Jeff Newman]

On Sep 29, 6:39 am, Pete Becker <p...@versatile coding.comwrote :

On 2007-09-28 19:41:44 -0400, tragomaskhalos
<dave.du.verg.. [e-mail] said:

On 28 Sep, 23:31,JeffNewma n<Jeffrey.M.New [e-mail] ote:
[snip]

The compile error is :
Test.cpp: In member function `void B::func2()':
Test.cpp:29: error: parse error before `;' token
where line 29 is the marked line.
Any help is greatly appreciated.

Comeau online accepts it OK - what compiler are
you using? If the answer is VC6 that's probably
your problem - search the archives of this group
for problems with this, esp w.r.t. templates.

The error message sounds like one from gcc. Search the archives of this
group for problems with this, esp w.r.t. templates.

--
Pete
Roundhouse Consulting, Ltd. (www.versatilecoding.com) Author of "The
Standard C++ Library Extensions: a Tutorial and Reference
(www.petebecker.com/tr1book)

Thanks for the help. The compiler was GCC 3.3, and it does appear to
be a bug in it. In case anyone else is searching for this issue, a
workaround is to take out the explicit type usage in func2 and just
allow the compiler figure out which version to call:

template<typena me Y>
void func2()
{
A a;
Y x = 0;
a.DoIt(x); // NOTE: This now compiles
}