BUG : Deployment Launch Conditions - Help

[Jo]

I am having a real problem with the Launch conditions in VS .NET and can
only come to the conclusion that it is a bug.

It states quite emphatically in the MSDN that Launch Conditions WILL be
executed in the order added. This statement holds true if every Condition
has a InstallURL value set. but not if there is no InstallURL value.

For Example :
I want to check that W2K exists on the target machine before installing SP4.
So, I add a Launch condition to check if versionNT=500.
I leave the InstallURL Blank as you are supposed to if you do not want the
user to continue and just display the OK button to terminate.
This works fine by itself

I add another Launch condition which check for SP4 viz. ServicePackLevel >=4
which has a InstallURL to enable me to install SP4 if it does not exist (ie
sp1, 2, 3 is installed)
As soon as I add it it jumps the queue and trie to install SP4 before even
checking in W2k is installed. ???

Add a MDAC Check with option to install and it executes after the SP4 check
(good)
remove the SP4 Checks InstallUrl (ie quit if SP4 or greater not found)
and MDAC jumps the queue.

This is a problem as I do not want to put a installURL in for W2K Check as I
don't want to install W2K (or the app) if the user is running W9x or NT or
XP and I definately don't want to install the SP if W2k does not exist
(granted that the SP install will moan, but too late!)

Things I have tried :
Launch condition addition in sequence of supposed execution ( no good)
Alphabetical Naming sequence, any addition order (no good)
Alphabetical Naming sequence with the correct addition order (no good)
Physically Editing and Swopping (in notepad) the entries n the .vdproj file
(no good)
Adding the W2K check into the default Framework Check section (which happens
before anything anyway) (no good)

Not that it makes a difference but the application I am building a package
for is written in C#...

Any Help on the matter would be greatly appreciated.

My Systems (tried it on all of them) :

All have the following Software : (and one JUST have this software, nothing
else so its nice and fresh)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
W2k SP4
VS.NET Architect edition
..Net Framework 1.1 (version : 1.1.4322)
Microsoft Development Environment (version : 7.1.3088)
Microsoft Visual C# .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Microsoft Visual Basic .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Microsoft Visual J# .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Crystal Reports for Visual Studio .NET AAP50-GS00000-U7000RN
IE6 sp1 (required by the VS.NET install)

All the VS.NET stuff is the latest that came with the 2003 MSDN
subscription.

Different Hardware
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Compaq P4 2.1GHz
512Mb DDR Ram
40GB HD

Dell Laptop P4 2.4GHz
512MB DDR Ram
40gb HD

Celeron 2.3GH
512MB DDR Ram
80GB HD

[Patrick Baker [MSFT]]

This does appear to be a bug. I will make sure one is logged with the
appropriate team.

You might try combining different conditions and boolean operators, but I
don't think that will work very well for you.
Another work-around you might try is to only do the W2K check as a Launch
Condition and do the SP4 check as a Custom Action at the Install Phase.
This will mean that the install will partially happen and a rollback will
be triggered however.
Patrick Baker - Visual Basic/Deployment Quality Assurance Team
This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

--------------------

From: "Jo" <jl**********@uskotec.com>
Newsgroups: microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp
Subject: BUG : Deployment Launch Conditions - Help
Date: Wed, 27 Aug 2003 23:17:54 +0200
X-Newsreader: Microsoft Outlook Express 6.00.2800.1106
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.00.2800.1106
Lines: 80
Message-ID: <3f**************@hades.is.co.za>
NNTP-Posting-Host: 196.26.134.32
X-Trace: hades.is.co.za 1062019140 64724 196.26.134.32
Path: cpmsftngxa06.phx.gbl!TK2MSFTNGP08.phx.gbl!newsfeed 00.sul.t-online.de!t-onlin
e.de!skynet.be!skynet.be!infeed.is.co.za!feeder.is .co.za!hades.is.co.za!not-
for-mailXref: cpmsftngxa06.phx.gbl microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp:180072
X-Tomcat-NG: microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp

I am having a real problem with the Launch conditions in VS .NET and can
only come to the conclusion that it is a bug.

It states quite emphatically in the MSDN that Launch Conditions WILL be
executed in the order added. This statement holds true if every Condition
has a InstallURL value set. but not if there is no InstallURL value.

For Example :
I want to check that W2K exists on the target machine before installing SP4.So, I add a Launch condition to check if versionNT=500.
I leave the InstallURL Blank as you are supposed to if you do not want the
user to continue and just display the OK button to terminate.
This works fine by itself

I add another Launch condition which check for SP4 viz. ServicePackLevel
=4
which has a InstallURL to enable me to install SP4 if it does not exist (ie
sp1, 2, 3 is installed)
As soon as I add it it jumps the queue and trie to install SP4 before even
checking in W2k is installed. ???

Add a MDAC Check with option to install and it executes after the SP4 check
(good)
remove the SP4 Checks InstallUrl (ie quit if SP4 or greater not found)
and MDAC jumps the queue.

This is a problem as I do not want to put a installURL in for W2K Check as Idon't want to install W2K (or the app) if the user is running W9x or NT or
XP and I definately don't want to install the SP if W2k does not exist
(granted that the SP install will moan, but too late!)

Things I have tried :
Launch condition addition in sequence of supposed execution ( no good)
Alphabetical Naming sequence, any addition order (no good)
Alphabetical Naming sequence with the correct addition order (no good)
Physically Editing and Swopping (in notepad) the entries n the .vdproj file
(no good)
Adding the W2K check into the default Framework Check section (which happensbefore anything anyway) (no good)

Not that it makes a difference but the application I am building a package
for is written in C#...

Any Help on the matter would be greatly appreciated.

My Systems (tried it on all of them) :

All have the following Software : (and one JUST have this software, nothing
else so its nice and fresh)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
W2k SP4
VS.NET Architect edition
.Net Framework 1.1 (version : 1.1.4322)
Microsoft Development Environment (version : 7.1.3088)
Microsoft Visual C# .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Microsoft Visual Basic .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Microsoft Visual J# .NET 69586-335-0000007-18303
Crystal Reports for Visual Studio .NET AAP50-GS00000-U7000RN
IE6 sp1 (required by the VS.NET install)

All the VS.NET stuff is the latest that came with the 2003 MSDN
subscription.

Different Hardware
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Compaq P4 2.1GHz
512Mb DDR Ram
40GB HD

Dell Laptop P4 2.4GHz
512MB DDR Ram
40gb HD

Celeron 2.3GH
512MB DDR Ram
80GB HD