Problem in invoking WebMethod at client side

[Ram P. Dash]

Hi:

I had the following client proxy code autogenerated:

Code I:
[System.Web.Serv ices.Protocols. SoapRpcMethodAt tribute("http://tempuri.org/ProcessCondensa teFile", RequestNamespac e="http://tempuri.org/", ResponseNamespa ce="http://tempuri.org/")]
public bool ProcessCondensa teFile(Condensa teFileContainer condensateFileC ontainer) {
object[] results = this.Invoke("Pr ocessCondensate File", new object[] {
condensateFileC ontainer});
return ((bool)(results[0]));
}
While debugging, I would loose control at this.Invoke(). i.e. The app never reached the return statement nor did it time-out (the default is 100). Not sure of what is happening, I overrode GetWebRequest() method of the client proxy to do the following:

Code II:
protected override WebRequest GetWebRequest(U ri uri)
{
HttpWebRequest webRequest = null;
try
{
webRequest = (HttpWebRequest ) DoWorkHandler(u ri);
}
catch (Exception e)
{
string msg = e.Message;
}
return webRequest;
}
private WebRequest DoWorkHandler(U ri uri)
{
return base.GetWebRequ est(uri);
}
Sure enough, I lost control in DoWorkHandler at the return statement. Armed with this information, I tried to call the DoWorkHandler asynchronously like below with my own timeout since the timeout of the webservice client proxy never worked at the first place:

Code III:
protected override WebRequest GetWebRequest(U ri uri)

{
HttpWebRequest webRequest = null;
try
{
WorkDelegate d = new WorkDelegate(Do WorkHandler);
IAsyncResult res = d.BeginInvoke(u ri,null,null);
if(res.IsComple ted == false)
{
res.AsyncWaitHa ndle.WaitOne(10 000,false);
if(res.IsComple ted == false)
throw new ApplicationExce ption("Timeout" );
}
webRequest = (HttpWebRequest ) d.EndInvoke((As yncResult)res);
}
catch (Exception e)
{
string msg = e.Message;
}
return webRequest;
}
Surprisingly this works. i.e. The request is passed to the service and I am getting a response back (no timeouts either). I would rather like to have Code I as opposed to Code III. Can somebody enlighten me as to why is this happening? I am working on a Windows XP workstation with Visual Studio 2003. My client and service are on the same box. I've at least 20 other services / clients running under same box using the same kind of interface without any hiccup.

Thanks,

Ram