A "basic" question - I think!

[Keith Rebello]

I have an object called ColumnSection which represents a reinforced concrete
column. This object contains an arraylist called Diagrams which contains
Graph2D objects which are essentially X-Y plots. The Graph2D object has 2
public methods - Draw, which draws the plot on a bitmap in memory and
DisplayGraph which blits the bitmap on to a Panel or PictureBox.

I have a public ReadOnly property in the ColumnSection called
InteractionDiagrams which returns the Diagrams arraylist. I want to be able
to get the arraylist in a form with a PictureBox.

Questions:

1. Should the InteractionDiagrams property return the Diagrams arraylist or
a clone of the Diagrams arraylist? Are there any issues either way?

2. Is there anything wrong in calling either the Draw or DisplayGraph
methods of the Graph2D objects in the Diagrams arraylist from the form with
the PictureBox?

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Keith.

[Mike McIntyre]

Keith,

Regarding (1): What will your code do with the Diagrams ArrayList?

Regarding (2): Not quite clear what you mean. Can you provide sample code?
--
Mike

Mike McIntyre
Visual Basic MVP
www.getdotnetcode.com
"Keith Rebello" <kr**@gecinc.com> wrote in message
news:Xv*******************@newsread1.mlpsca01.us.t o.verio.net...

I have an object called ColumnSection which represents a reinforced
concrete
column. This object contains an arraylist called Diagrams which contains
Graph2D objects which are essentially X-Y plots. The Graph2D object has 2
public methods - Draw, which draws the plot on a bitmap in memory and
DisplayGraph which blits the bitmap on to a Panel or PictureBox.

I have a public ReadOnly property in the ColumnSection called
InteractionDiagrams which returns the Diagrams arraylist. I want to be
able
to get the arraylist in a form with a PictureBox.

Questions:

1. Should the InteractionDiagrams property return the Diagrams arraylist
or
a clone of the Diagrams arraylist? Are there any issues either way?

2. Is there anything wrong in calling either the Draw or DisplayGraph
methods of the Graph2D objects in the Diagrams arraylist from the form
with
the PictureBox?

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Keith.

[Keith Rebello]

Mike,

The InteractionDiagrams property will be one of the following:

Get
Return Diagrams
or
Return Diagrams.Clone
End Get

My question is which "Return" should I use.

Once I have the Diagrams arraylist in my calling form (the one with the
PictureBox), I want to be able to do:

Dim Gr2D as Graph2D
Gr2D= Diagrams(i)
Gr2D.DisplayGraph

Is this permissible?

"Mike McIntyre" <mi****@dotnetshowandtell.com> wrote in message
news:eu**************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

Keith,

Regarding (1): What will your code do with the Diagrams ArrayList?

Regarding (2): Not quite clear what you mean. Can you provide sample code?

--
Mike

Mike McIntyre
Visual Basic MVP
www.getdotnetcode.com
"Keith Rebello" <kr**@gecinc.com> wrote in message
news:Xv*******************@newsread1.mlpsca01.us.t o.verio.net...

I have an object called ColumnSection which represents a reinforced
concrete
column. This object contains an arraylist called Diagrams which contains Graph2D objects which are essentially X-Y plots. The Graph2D object has 2 public methods - Draw, which draws the plot on a bitmap in memory and
DisplayGraph which blits the bitmap on to a Panel or PictureBox.

I have a public ReadOnly property in the ColumnSection called
InteractionDiagrams which returns the Diagrams arraylist. I want to be
able
to get the arraylist in a form with a PictureBox.

Questions:

1. Should the InteractionDiagrams property return the Diagrams arraylist or
a clone of the Diagrams arraylist? Are there any issues either way?

2. Is there anything wrong in calling either the Draw or DisplayGraph
methods of the Graph2D objects in the Diagrams arraylist from the form
with
the PictureBox?

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Keith.

[Mike McIntyre]

Keith,

In this scenario there appears to be no reason to Clone.

Mike
"Keith Rebello" <kr**@gecinc.com> wrote in message
news:HW*******************@newsread1.mlpsca01.us.t o.verio.net...

Mike,

The InteractionDiagrams property will be one of the following:

Get
Return Diagrams
or
Return Diagrams.Clone
End Get

My question is which "Return" should I use.

Once I have the Diagrams arraylist in my calling form (the one with the
PictureBox), I want to be able to do:

Dim Gr2D as Graph2D
Gr2D= Diagrams(i)
Gr2D.DisplayGraph

Is this permissible?

"Mike McIntyre" <mi****@dotnetshowandtell.com> wrote in message
news:eu**************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

Keith,

Regarding (1): What will your code do with the Diagrams ArrayList?

Regarding (2): Not quite clear what you mean. Can you provide sample

code?

--
Mike

Mike McIntyre
Visual Basic MVP
www.getdotnetcode.com
"Keith Rebello" <kr**@gecinc.com> wrote in message
news:Xv*******************@newsread1.mlpsca01.us.t o.verio.net...

>I have an object called ColumnSection which represents a reinforced
>concrete
> column. This object contains an arraylist called Diagrams which contains > Graph2D objects which are essentially X-Y plots. The Graph2D object
> has 2 > public methods - Draw, which draws the plot on a bitmap in memory and
> DisplayGraph which blits the bitmap on to a Panel or PictureBox.
>
> I have a public ReadOnly property in the ColumnSection called
> InteractionDiagrams which returns the Diagrams arraylist. I want to be
> able
> to get the arraylist in a form with a PictureBox.
>
> Questions:
>
> 1. Should the InteractionDiagrams property return the Diagrams arraylist > or
> a clone of the Diagrams arraylist? Are there any issues either way?
>
> 2. Is there anything wrong in calling either the Draw or DisplayGraph
> methods of the Graph2D objects in the Diagrams arraylist from the form
> with
> the PictureBox?
>
> Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
>
> Keith.
>
>