PIL: Getting a two color difference between images

[Kevin D. Smith]

I'm trying to get the difference of two images using PIL. The
ImageChops.difference function does almost what I want, but it takes
the absolute value of the pixel difference. What I want is a two color
output image: black where the image wasn't different, and white where
it was different. Right now I get black where it wasn't different, and
abs(image1-image2) where it was different.

It would be nice if I could specify the colors for difference and no
difference. This sounds like it should be easy, but I just don't see
how to do it.

--
Kevin D. Smith

[Lie Ryan]

On Fri, 24 Oct 2008 14:51:07 -0500, Kevin D. Smith wrote:

I'm trying to get the difference of two images using PIL. The
ImageChops.difference function does almost what I want, but it takes the
absolute value of the pixel difference. What I want is a two color
output image: black where the image wasn't different, and white where it
was different. Right now I get black where it wasn't different, and
abs(image1-image2) where it was different.

It would be nice if I could specify the colors for difference and no
difference. This sounds like it should be easy, but I just don't see
how to do it.

--
Kevin D. Smith

Use the Image.point()

Also, see PIL Handbook: http://www.pythonware.com/library/pil/handbook/
index.htm

[bearophileHUGS]

Kevin D. Smith:

What I want is a two color output image: black where the image wasn't different, and white where it was different.<

There are several ways to do that. If speed isn't essential, then you
can create a third blank image of the right size, and then use the
method that iterates on the pixels of an image, and assign p1 != p2 at
every pixel of the third image.

If speed is important you can copy the images into numpy arrays and
then your operation becomes easy.

Maybe there are built-in ways in PIL too, I don't know. You can also
find an intermediate solution, like computing the difference image
with PIL and then binarize it manually.

Bye,
bearophile

[Lie Ryan]

Kevin D. Smith:

>What I want is a two color output image: black where the image wasn't
different, and white where it was different.<

Use the ImageChops.difference, which would give a difference image. Then
map all colors to white except black using Image.point()

[Kevin D. Smith]

On 2008-10-25 12:41:51 -0500, be************@lycos.com said:

Kevin D. Smith:

>What I want is a two color output image: black where the image wasn't
different, and white where it was different.<

There are several ways to do that. If speed isn't essential, then you
can create a third blank image of the right size, and then use the
method that iterates on the pixels of an image, and assign p1 != p2 at
every pixel of the third image.

If speed is important you can copy the images into numpy arrays and
then your operation becomes easy.

Maybe there are built-in ways in PIL too, I don't know. You can also
find an intermediate solution, like computing the difference image
with PIL and then binarize it manually.

This last method is what I ended up doing for now. I use the PIL
differencing function, then walk through the result of getdata() to
binarize it. I was hoping there might be a way to run a filter or
something that might be faster, but I haven't figured it out.

--
Kevin D. Smith