segfault when strcmp

[Robert Mens]

Hi,

I've got this problem with this project i am working on, i am
a bit new to c so i don't know why this happens.

string is read from a telnet socket.

Here's the piece of code that segfaults:

struct login_usertable{
char username;
char password;
int status; /* 0=disconnected, 1=need password, 2=connected */
};

struct login_usertable user;

int login_fillusers(){
user.username="robert";
user.password="test";
user.status=0;
}

int login_requesthandler(int socket,char *string){
if(user.status==0) login_showlogin(socket, 0);
if(user.status==1){
if(strcmp((char *)user.username,string)==0){ //segfaults
printf("logged in\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 1);
}else{
printf("err\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 0);
}
}
}

What's wrong with it?

Thanks in Advance,

Robert

--
ln[dot]tenlap[at]snem_trebor
read reversed and fill dot&at for email

[Joona I Palaste]

Robert Mens <ro*********@hotmail.com> scribbled the following:

Hi, I've got this problem with this project i am working on, i am
a bit new to c so i don't know why this happens. string is read from a telnet socket. Here's the piece of code that segfaults: struct login_usertable{
char username;
Take a close look at the declaration of this field. Note the type.
char password;
int status; /* 0=disconnected, 1=need password, 2=connected */
}; struct login_usertable user; int login_fillusers(){
user.username="robert";
You are shoving a char * into a char. Undefined behaviour.
user.password="test";
user.status=0;
} int login_requesthandler(int socket,char *string){
if(user.status==0) login_showlogin(socket, 0);
if(user.status==1){
if(strcmp((char *)user.username,string)==0){ //segfaults
The undefined behaviour in the first line of login_fillusers()
already destroyed all hope of user.username being a valid char *
value. No amount of casting will magically change it back. Thus
this strcmp() call is pointless.
printf("logged in\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 1);
}else{
printf("err\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 0);
}
}
} What's wrong with it?

Try changing the char fields in struct login_usertable to char * and
see if it works.

--
/-- Joona Palaste (pa*****@cc.helsinki.fi) ------------- Finland --------\
\-- http://www.helsinki.fi/~palaste --------------------- rules! --------/
"Immanuel Kant but Genghis Khan."
- The Official Graffitist's Handbook

[Andreas Kahari]

In article <bn**********@reader11.wxs.nl>, Robert Mens wrote:

Hi,

I've got this problem with this project i am working on, i am
a bit new to c so i don't know why this happens.

string is read from a telnet socket.

Here's the piece of code that segfaults:

struct login_usertable{
char username;
char password;
int status; /* 0=disconnected, 1=need password, 2=connected */
};

struct login_usertable user;

int login_fillusers(){
user.username="robert";
user.password="test";

Both user.username and user.password are characters, not
strings. Therefore you can't make those two assignments.

Try this instead:

#define MAXLENGTH 64

struct login_usertable {
char username[MAXLENGTH];
char password[MAXLENGTH];
int status;
}

int login_fillusers()
{
strncpy(user.username, "robert", MAXLENGTH);
strncpy(user.password, "piggsvin", MAXLENGTH);
/* etc. */
Read up on strings in some book.
--
Andreas Kähäri

[Mark Gordon]

On Wed, 22 Oct 2003 22:04:27 +0200
Robert Mens <ro*********@hotmail.com> wrote:

Hi,

I've got this problem with this project i am working on, i am
a bit new to c so i don't know why this happens.

string is read from a telnet socket.

Here's the piece of code that segfaults:
#include <string.h> /* for string functions */
#include <stdio.h> /* for printf and friends */
struct login_usertable{
char username;
char password;
char *username;
char *password;

/*
This was your big problem. You want pointer to strings if you are going
to make them point to something, which you do below. A single char as
you declared them can only store a single character.

Alternatively you might want character arrays, depending on what the
rest of your program is. However, you would then have to change your
login_fillusers function.
*/
int status; /* 0=disconnected, 1=need password, 2=connected */
};

struct login_usertable user;

int login_fillusers(){ void login_fillusers(){

/* You don't return a value, so tell the compiler the truth */
user.username="robert";
user.password="test";
user.status=0;
}

int login_requesthandler(int socket,char *string){ void login_requesthandler(int socket,char *string){

/* Again, you don't return an int so don't tell the compiler you will */
if(user.status==0) login_showlogin(socket, 0);
if(user.status==1){
if(strcmp((char *)user.username,string)==0){
if(strcmp(user.username,string)==0){
/*
I bet you added the cast above to shut up the compiler. That was wrong,
the compiler was warning because YOU had got it wrong.
*/
//segfaults /*
The // style comment was introduced in C99 and may not be supported by
your compiler when invoked in conforming mode (something you should do)
so it is better to use the old style comments like I have been doing.

Old style comments also survive reformatting on posting to Usenet
whereas // style comments often get broken.
*/
printf("logged in\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 1);
}else{
printf("err\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 0);
}
}
}

What's wrong with it?

See above.

For the future you should find out how to invoke your compiler in ISO
compliant mode with a a high level of warnings. I got masses of warnings
when I did this. Also don't ignore warnings or silence them with casts
since at your level I don't think you know enough to understand which
warnings you can ignore.
--
Mark Gordon
Paid to be a Geek & a Senior Software Developer
Although my email address says spamtrap, it is real and I read it.

[Robert Mens]

Robert Mens wrote:

Hi,

I've got this problem with this project i am working on, i am
a bit new to c so i don't know why this happens.

string is read from a telnet socket.

Here's the piece of code that segfaults:

struct login_usertable{
char username;
char password;
int status; /* 0=disconnected, 1=need password, 2=connected */
};

struct login_usertable user;

int login_fillusers(){
user.username="robert";
user.password="test";
user.status=0;
}

int login_requesthandler(int socket,char *string){
if(user.status==0) login_showlogin(socket, 0);
if(user.status==1){
if(strcmp((char *)user.username,string)==0){ //segfaults
printf("logged in\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 1);
}else{
printf("err\n");
login_showlogin(socket, 0);
}
}
}

What's wrong with it?

Thanks in Advance,

Robert

Thanks a lot for your answers
solved it now by places the char * thingys
--
ln[dot]tenalp[at]snem_trebor
read reversed and fill dot&at for email

[Mathew Hendry]

On Wed, 22 Oct 2003 20:39:45 +0000 (UTC), Andreas Kahari
<ak*******@freeshell.org> wrote:

strncpy(user.username, "robert", MAXLENGTH);
strncpy(user.password, "piggsvin", MAXLENGTH);
/* etc. */

I wouldn't recommend strncpy here - it doesn't terminate the string if it's
too long to fit. Use strncat instead, after initialising the first element
of the destination to zero.

-- Mat.

[Peter Nilsson]

Mathew Hendry <md****@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote in message news:<ro********************************@4ax.com>. ..

On Wed, 22 Oct 2003 20:39:45 +0000 (UTC), Andreas Kahari
<ak*******@freeshell.org> wrote:

strncpy(user.username, "robert", MAXLENGTH);
strncpy(user.password, "piggsvin", MAXLENGTH);
/* etc. */

I wouldn't recommend strncpy here - it doesn't terminate the string if it's
too long to fit.

It rather depends on the intended usage. Maximum memory utilisation of
fixed width fields is exactly what strncpy was designed for.

Of course, subsequent use of the field as an assumed string (e.g. with
strcmp) is not likely to have a good outcome.

However, fprintf specifically supports such fields too...

printf("%.*s\n", MAXLENGTH, user.username);

....as the argument to %s need only be an array, it needn't be a
string.

--
Peter