how can i return null when returning a struct

[Digital Fart]

I have the following function that returns a struct

public struct layout
{
public string str;
public int i;
}

function in some class where i loop through an arraylist of structs

public layout getLayout(string s)
{
foreach ( layout l in layoutArray)
if ( l.str == s ) return l;
}

but this does not compile because when i can't find l.str == s
what should i return then?

[Nick Hounsome]

"Digital Fart" <pr*********@angelfire.com> wrote in message
news:0t********************************@4ax.com...

I have the following function that returns a struct

public struct layout
{
public string str;
public int i;
}

function in some class where i loop through an arraylist of structs

public layout getLayout(string s)
{
foreach ( layout l in layoutArray)
if ( l.str == s ) return l;
}

but this does not compile because when i can't find l.str == s
what should i return then?

1) return a default layout
or
2) throw an exception
or
3) make it a class and return null

[Marc Gravell]

In 2.0 you could return "layout?" (i.e. Nullable<layout>), but I'm not sure
its a good anwser.

Could throw an exception?

Could refactor as:

public bool TryGetLayout(string s, out layout item) {
foreach(layout l in layoutArray) {
if(l.str == s) {
item= l;
return true;
}
}
item = default(layout); // or new layout();
return false;
}

Perhaps

Marc

[Clive Dixon]

If you're using C# 2.0 you could use nullable types and return a 'layout?'
type (lookup nullable types and System.Nullable in the documentation)

If not, you can't have such a thing as a null struct. You would have to do
something like return an object type instead and have the caller unbox, have
a special return struct value meaning "null" or return as a ref param and
have an error code as the return of the function.

"Digital Fart" <pr*********@angelfire.com> wrote in message
news:0t********************************@4ax.com...

I have the following function that returns a struct

public struct layout
{
public string str;
public int i;
}

function in some class where i loop through an arraylist of structs

public layout getLayout(string s)
{
foreach ( layout l in layoutArray)
if ( l.str == s ) return l;
}

but this does not compile because when i can't find l.str == s
what should i return then?