self.var hmm?

[notnorwegian]

class TaskGroup:
def __init__(self):
self.group = []

def addTask(self, task):
self.group.append(task)
is this wrong? i have a program thats too big to post but should i
just do group.append in addTask?

reason is when later doing TaskGroup.group i get None

[Martin Marcher]

Hi,

that's because

self.group is not the same as TaskGroup.group

quickish:

class TaskGroup
group = []
def __init__(self):
"""
## note that all TaskGroup instances now use the the same self.group
"""
self.group = TaskGroup.group
def addTask(self, task):
self.group.append(task)

hth
martin

On Tue, May 20, 2008 at 10:58 PM, <no**********@yahoo.sewrote:

class TaskGroup:
def __init__(self):
self.group = []

def addTask(self, task):
self.group.append(task)
is this wrong? i have a program thats too big to post but should i
just do group.append in addTask?

reason is when later doing TaskGroup.group i get None

--
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

--
http://www.xing.com/profile/Martin_Marcher

You are not free to read this message,
by doing so, you have violated my licence
and are required to urinate publicly. Thank you.

[Paul Boddie]

On 20 Mai, 22:58, [e-mail] wrote:

class TaskGroup:
def __init__(self):
self.group = []

def addTask(self, task):
self.group.append(task)

is this wrong? i have a program thats too big to post but should i
just do group.append in addTask?

No, you have to do self.group.append, since group isn't a local
variable in the addTask method, and I doubt that you'd want addTask to
make changes to any global variable called group, which is what might
happen otherwise - that could be a source of potential problems, so
you need to be aware of that!

reason is when later doing TaskGroup.group i get None

TaskGroup.group would be referencing a class attribute called group,
which is "shared" by all TaskGroup instances (and the TaskGroup class
itself, of course). What you need to do is to access the instance
attribute called group via each instance, and the self.group notation
does exactly that: self is the reference to a particular instance (in
the addTask method, it's the instance used to call the addTask
method).

You might wonder why Python doesn't know inside a method that group is
a reference to an instance attribute of that name. The reason,
somewhat simplified, is that Python only has assignments to populate
namespaces (such as the contents of an instance), whereas languages
which employ declarations (such as Java) would have you list the
instance attributes up front. In these other languages, the compiler/
interpreter would know that you're executing a method belonging to an
instance of a particular class, and it would also know what names to
expect as references to class and instance attributes.

Anyway, I hope this makes more sense now than it did a few moments
ago. :-)

Paul