how to browse using urllib2 and cookeilib the correct way

[jnair]

Hi ,

I am using python2.4 "urllib2" and "cookelib".
In line "5" below i provide my credentials to
login into a web site.During the first attempt i "fail",
judging from the output of line "6".
I try again and the second time i succeed,judging
from the output of line "8".

Now using the "twill" module (http://www.idyll.org/~t/www-tools/twill/)
it suceeds in the first attempt(lines "10" to "19").

can anybody explain, in the first case why i need to do two attempts.
1) >>>import urllib2,urllib,cookielib
2) >>>cj = cookielib.CookieJar()
3) >>>opener = urllib2.build_opener( urllib2.HTTPCookieProcessor(cj))
4) >>>data = urllib.urlencode( { "username" : "user" , "password" :
"****" } )
5) >>>fp = opener.open(
"https://rhn.redhat.com/rhn/LoginSubmit.do",data )
6) >>>fp.url

'https://rhn.redhat.com/rhn/ReLogin.do?url_bounce=/network/index.pxt'
7) >>>fp = opener.open(
"https://rhn.redhat.com/rhn/LoginSubmit.do",data )
8) >>>fp.url
'https://rhn.redhat.com/network/index.pxt'

#twill module

10) >>>from twill.commands import *
11) >>>go("https://rhn.redhat.com")
12) ==> at https://rhn.redhat.com
13) 'https://rhn.redhat.com'
14) >>>fv("2","username","eipl")
15) >>>fv("2","password","ensim1234")
16) >>>submit()
17) Note: submit is using submit button: name="None", value=" Â Sign
In "
18) >>>url('https://rhn.redhat.com/network/index.pxt')
19) 'https://rhn.redhat.com/network/index.pxt'

Thanks
Jitu

[Edward Elliott]

jn***@ensim.com wrote:

can anybody explain, in the first case why i need to do two attempts.

I would guess it's because redhat requires your browser to submit a session
cookie with the login form. In the urllib2 example, the first request you
make tries to submit login form data directly. Since it's your first hit
on their site, you don't have a cookie yet. People browsing interactively
would at least load the login page first before submitting it.

Your twill example takes care of this by requesting a page before trying to
login.

That would be my guess.

[jnair]

ok , got it . Thanks

[John J. Lee]

Edward Elliott <no****@127.0.0.1> writes:

jn***@ensim.com wrote:

can anybody explain, in the first case why i need to do two attempts.

I would guess it's because redhat requires your browser to submit a session
cookie with the login form. In the urllib2 example, the first request you
make tries to submit login form data directly. Since it's your first hit
on their site, you don't have a cookie yet. People browsing interactively
would at least load the login page first before submitting it.

Your twill example takes care of this by requesting a page before trying to
login.

That would be my guess.

Uh, yeah you're right actually. Forget what I said about Refresh...
John