Command line output bypasses my capture!

[jdbartlett]

I'm trying to capture output from a command line utility (XMLSec), but
only get an empty result. If I call the script from the command line,
I see XMLSec's output, but I can't seem to capture it!

My PHP installation is working correctly and captures other command
line output just fine, XMLSec is the only exception I've found. I've
also tried a couple of other systems to confirm this behavior.

Capture methods I've tried include:

- shell_exec

- exec, with and without output array

- system

- passthru combined with output buffering

- fread-ing from popen('xmlsec1...', 'r')

- proc_open

I get the same result for each of these: an empty string (or array in
the case of exec's $output).

Any idea what's happening here? Any help would be much appreciated.

[Andy Hassall]

On Mon, 20 Aug 2007 19:33:58 -0000, jdbartlett <co*****@jdbartlett.comwrote:

>I'm trying to capture output from a command line utility (XMLSec), but
only get an empty result. If I call the script from the command line,
I see XMLSec's output, but I can't seem to capture it!

My PHP installation is working correctly and captures other command
line output just fine, XMLSec is the only exception I've found. I've
also tried a couple of other systems to confirm this behavior.

Capture methods I've tried include:

- shell_exec

- exec, with and without output array

- system

- passthru combined with output buffering

- fread-ing from popen('xmlsec1...', 'r')

- proc_open

I get the same result for each of these: an empty string (or array in
the case of exec's $output).

Any idea what's happening here? Any help would be much appreciated.

Is it writing to stderr (standard error) instead of stdout (standard output)?
--
Andy Hassall :: an**@andyh.co.uk :: http://www.andyh.co.uk
http://www.andyhsoftware.co.uk/space :: disk and FTP usage analysis tool

[jdbartlett]

On Aug 20, 3:39 pm, Andy Hassall <[e-mail]:

On Mon, 20 Aug 2007 19:33:58 -0000, jdbartlett <[e-mail]:

I'm trying to capture output from a command line utility (XMLSec), but
only get an empty result. If I call the script from the command line,
I see XMLSec's output, but I can't seem to capture it!

My PHP installation is working correctly and captures other command
line output just fine, XMLSec is the only exception I've found. I've
also tried a couple of other systems to confirm this behavior.

Capture methods I've tried include:

- shell_exec

- exec, with and without output array

- system

- passthru combined with output buffering

- fread-ing from popen('xmlsec1...', 'r')

- proc_open

I get the same result for each of these: an empty string (or array in
the case of exec's $output).

Any idea what's happening here? Any help would be much appreciated.

Is it writing to stderr (standard error) instead of stdout (standard output)?
--
Andy Hassall :: [e-mail] ::http://www.andyh.co.ukhttp://www.and....co.uk/space:: disk and FTP usage analysis tool

One of those slap-forehead-with-palm "D'oh! I'm an idiot!" moments.

Thank you! Yes, of course, that's exactly what's happening.

IMO, that's a very odd way for a utility to act, but that doesn't make
me feel any less an idiot!

For anyone stumbling into this thread with a similar problem, you need
to reroute stderr to stdout (and stdout to /dev/null if you want
errors only), like so:

var_dump(shell_exec('xmlsec1 verify --id-attr:id Body --trusted-pem
my_public.crt my_signed.xml * 2>&1 1>/dev/null'));

Thanks again!