xmlns in XHTML

Saqib Ali

Hello All,

I am using Norman Walsh's XSLTs to transform some DocBook XML content
to HTML.

However I noticed that Norman Walsh's DocBook XSLT includes the
following
tag in the transformed document:
<meta xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" ......

I think the XML Namespace can only be declared in <html/> tag for
e.g.:
<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en">
is the correct way to declare the namespace.

<meta xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" ...... is what Norman
Walsh's
XSLT produced, which I think is incorrect. I might be wrong.

Before I submit a bug-report to OASIS, I just to make sure that I m
not missing something. Let me know if I am wrong about xmlns
declaration.

Here are some sample documents transformed from DocBook XML to HTML
using Norman's XSLTs: http://www.xml-dev.com/blog/#88

Thanks.
Saqib Ali
-------------
http://validate.sf.net <---- (X)HTML / DocBook XML Validator and
Transformer

Jul 20 '05 #1

Subscribe Post Reply

2110

Andy Dingley

On 5 May 2004 10:39:31 -0700, sa***@stonebeat.org (Saqib Ali) wrote:

Before I submit a bug-report to OASIS, I just to make sure that I m
not missing something.
Here's a clue - Norman Walsh _really_ knows what he's doing. Many,
many people have also used those stylesheets over and over. I'm not
saying there are no bugs left, but obvious ones get found quickly.
Let me know if I am wrong about xmlns
declaration.

Yes.

Jul 20 '05 #2

Saqib Ali

> >Let me know if I am wrong about xmlns

declaration.

Yes.

Can you please be more specific as to where in the XHTML DTD it allows
the xmlns attribute to be in the <META /> TAG ???

I was looking at the XHTML DTD @ http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/#dtds it
seems like xmlns attribute is only allowed in the <html /> TAG.

Can you please point me to the exact location in the DTD, which allows
xmlns attribute to be in the <meta /> tag.

Thanks.
In Peace,
Saqib Ali
http://validate.sf.net

Jul 20 '05 #3

Derek Harmon

"Saqib Ali" <sa***@stonebeat.org> wrote in message news:d2**************************@posting.google.c om...

Can you please be more specific as to where in the XHTML DTD it allows
the xmlns attribute to be in the <META /> TAG ???
I was looking at the XHTML DTD @ http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/#dtds it
seems like xmlns attribute is only allowed in the <html /> TAG.

Observe that the xmlns attribute on the html tag is FIXED. The inference
drawn from this is that all the child elements defined by the DTD must
belong to the same namespace URI, and no others.

The "XML with Namespaces" recommendation (on which XHTML
is based) was created to address this limitation. Inherent in this
recommendation is the freedom to declare namespaces anyplace.

The relationship between XHTML and other namespaces is described
in section 3.1.2 of the XHTML 1.0 recommendation,

http://www.w3.org/TR/2000/REC-xhtml1...6/#well-formed

If you must validate against a DTD, since DTDs are incapable of
supporting namespaces, then the XHTML produced by the Doc-
Book XSLT is not strictly conforming. This is due to a known
limitation of the DTD, rather than incongrueity with the XHTML
recommendation.

XHTML 1.1 includes informative XML Schemas, that accomodate
the broader use of XML namespace declarations.
Derek Harmon

Jul 20 '05 #4

Andy Dingley

sa***@stonebeat.org (Saqib Ali) wrote in message

Can you please point me to the exact location in the DTD, which allows
xmlns attribute to be in the <meta /> tag.

It's not in the DTD - xmlns is "magic" (it's part of XML, not XHTML),
so look at the XML TR instead
http://www.w3.org/TR/2004/REC-xml11-20040204/

or more specifically, at the TR for namespacing in XML
http://www.w3.org/TR/2004/REC-xml-na...40204/#ns-decl

Jul 20 '05 #5

Richard Tobin

In article <d2**************************@posting.google.com >,
Saqib Ali <sa***@stonebeat.org> wrote:

<meta xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" ...... is what Norman
Walsh's XSLT produced, which I think is incorrect. I might be wrong.

DTDs and namespaces don't work very well together, so it may well be
invalid according to the DTD, and you may just want to ignore that
fact.

Furthermore there may be some variation between XSLT processors as to
what xmlns declarations they output, so it's very hard to guarantee
output that matches a DTD.

However, looking at one of your examples, I'm baffled. The top-level
<html> element doesn't have an xmlns attribute. The #FIXED
declaration in the DTD will give it one when it's read back in again,
but the XSLT processor that generated it didn't know that. In fact,
it looks as if none of the XSLT output except the meta element was in
the XHTML namespace, and that's why it put the xmlns attribute on
the meta element.

The first thing I'd do is try using a different XSLT processor.
Then ask Norm.

-- Richard

Jul 20 '05 #6

Saqib Ali

> The "XML with Namespaces" recommendation (on which XHTML

is based) was created to address this limitation. Inherent in this
recommendation is the freedom to declare namespaces anyplace.

The relationship between XHTML and other namespaces is described
in section 3.1.2 of the XHTML 1.0 recommendation,

http://www.w3.org/TR/2000/REC-xhtml1...6/#well-formed

Derek,
Thank you very much. This is exactly what I was looking for. :)

In Peace,
Saqib Ali
http://validate.sf.net

Jul 20 '05 #7

Nick Kew

In article <c7************@id-185805.news.uni-berlin.de>,
"Derek Harmon" <lo*******@email.msn.com> writes:

"Saqib Ali" <sa***@stonebeat.org> wrote in message news:d2**************************@posting.google.c om...
Can you please be more specific as to where in the XHTML DTD it allows
the xmlns attribute to be in the <META /> TAG ???
I was looking at the XHTML DTD @ http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/#dtds it
seems like xmlns attribute is only allowed in the <html /> TAG.

You may be talking at cross-purposes. XML namespace rules and DTD
validation rules are different beasts. XHTML, and particularly XHTML1.0,
applies the latter. So <meta xmlns... /> is fine by XML rules but
invalid by XHTML rules.

As for whether the stylesheets are in error - I'd have to spend more
time than I have now to determine whether the error lies there or in
the user. But in reply to Andy's point, Norman Walsh may know what
he's doing, but Saqib in no ignorant newbie either.
Observe that the xmlns attribute on the html tag is FIXED. The inference
drawn from this is that all the child elements defined by the DTD must
belong to the same namespace URI, and no others.
What FIXED means is that it's implied in the <html> element even when
an author omits it. It doesn't prevent use of other default namespaces
through an xmlns attribute on a child element.
The "XML with Namespaces" recommendation (on which XHTML
is based) was created to address this limitation. Inherent in this
recommendation is the freedom to declare namespaces anyplace.

The relationship between XHTML and other namespaces is described
in section 3.1.2 of the XHTML 1.0 recommendation,

http://www.w3.org/TR/2000/REC-xhtml1...6/#well-formed
This is a case of design by committee pulling in different and
mutually incompatible directions. The only way this actually works
is by defining new DTDs (such as XHTML+MATHML+SVG). Or by dropping
both validation and browser-compatibility.
If you must validate against a DTD, since DTDs are incapable of
supporting namespaces,
Not strictly true, but we'll skip over that.
then the XHTML produced by the Doc-
Book XSLT is not strictly conforming.
Neither is it valid if it generates xmlns declarations in the manner
described here.
XHTML 1.1 includes informative XML Schemas, that accomodate
the broader use of XML namespace declarations.

XHTML 1.1 is a true exercise in futility. It gratuitously breaks
browser-compatibility, but offers nothing in return, beyond what
ad-hoc-XML gives us for free in terms of availability of processing
tools.

Conclusion: XML and HTML each has advantages. But mixing them
requires attention to detail that is often missing.

--
Nick Kew

Nick's manifesto: http://www.htmlhelp.com/~nick/

Jul 20 '05 #8

Richard Tobin

In article <65************@webthing.com>,
Nick Kew <ni**@hugin.webthing.com> wrote:

What FIXED means is that it's implied in the <html> element even when
an author omits it.

*And* that the author may not supply any other value, unlike a plain default.

-- Richard

Jul 20 '05 #9

Patrick TJ McPhee

In article <28**************************@posting.google.com >,
Andy Dingley <di*****@codesmiths.com> wrote:
% sa***@stonebeat.org (Saqib Ali) wrote in message
%
% > Can you please point me to the exact location in the DTD, which allows
% > xmlns attribute to be in the <meta /> tag.
%
% It's not in the DTD - xmlns is "magic" (it's part of XML, not XHTML),
% so look at the XML TR instead

It's magic, but if you want to validate against a DTD, you've got to
include the xmlns* attributes, as well as having the prefix consistent
between the instance and the DTD.
--

Patrick TJ McPhee
East York Canada
pt**@interlog.com

Jul 20 '05 #10

Andy Dingley

pt**@interlog.com (Patrick TJ McPhee) wrote in message news:<c7**********@news.eusc.inter.net>...

It's magic, but if you want to validate against a DTD, you've got to
include the xmlns* attributes, as well as having the prefix consistent
between the instance and the DTD.

Are there any well-known validators that work correctly for XHTML with
embedded elements from other namesapces ?

Is there even as yet an agreed notion of what "correct" means in this
case ? I know there's a certain lack of clarity(sic) in how close
XHTML is to being "vanilla" XML (for reasons of HTML legacyness). It's
easy to treat XHTML + (X-foo) as an XML document and validate it as
such, but a lot harder to take a "post HTML, App C aware" tool and
persuade it that your document is valid.

Jul 20 '05 #11

by: Peter Maas | last post by:

Hi, I have a problem parsing html text with xmldom. The following code runs well: -------------------------------------------- from xml.dom.ext.reader import HtmlLib from xml.dom.ext import...

Python

xmlns query for mathml

by: Jon Thackray | last post by:

I'm trying to use the MathML DTD and stylesheets, but get some problems with xmlns attributes. If I do something like <math xmlns="http://..."> .... </math> then xmllint and xalan in...

.NET Framework

xmlns in XHTML

by: Saqib Ali | last post by:

Hello All, I am using Norman Walsh's XSLTs to transform some DocBook XML content to HTML. However I noticed that Norman Walsh's DocBook XSLT includes the following tag in the transformed...

HTML / CSS

roundtripping and xmlns attributes

by: Gary Stephenson | last post by:

I am endeavouring to use .NET v2.0 XML facilities to "roundtrip" reading and writing XML documents - i.e. to end up with _exactly_ what I started with, but I can't seem to figure out how to get an...

.NET Framework

XSL problem matching node containing xmlns attribute

by: clover2411 | last post by:

Hi there, Apologies if I'm posting to the wrong group; this one looked to be the best match. I'm having trouble writing a bit of XSL/XPATH and wondered if someone would please shed some...

.NET Framework

Extracting the xmlns:v attribute out of an HTML element in IE?

by: aglaforge | last post by:

I'm attempting to write a quick piece of Javascript code that will validate if the end user of the javascript has the necessary VML attributes set in their HTML. The problem in IE is that...

Javascript

xmlns attribute produces XHTML validation error.

by: C.W.Holeman II | last post by:

I have an xmlns attribute that produces an XHTML validation error and I do not understand why it is considered an error.The file displays as expected on Firefox and IE7. ...

.NET Framework

ElementTree find with xmlns

by: cakebread | last post by:

I'm having problems parsing a file: <body>Hello world</body> </html>""") None The above works fine with the first element being a simple <html>, but not when I have all the xmlns's.

Python

can't get rid of xmlns attribute

by: Dormilich | last post by:

Hi, I have some problems removing the xmlns attributes from a transformed xml file. I can't completely remove them (so it would validate). the problematic elements are <div> or the elements...

XML

How to Use CodiumAI's pr-agent?

by: erikbower65 | last post by:

Using CodiumAI's pr-agent is simple and powerful. Follow these steps: 1. Install CodiumAI CLI: Ensure Node.js is installed, then run 'npm install -g codiumai' in the terminal. 2. Connect to...

General

Speedup your spring application

by: linyimin | last post by:

Spring Startup Analyzer generates an interactive Spring application startup report that lets you understand what contributes to the application startup time and helps to optimize it. Support for...

General

Steps manually installing IntelliJ IDEA.

by: erikbower65 | last post by:

Here's a concise step-by-step guide for manually installing IntelliJ IDEA: 1. Download: Visit the official JetBrains website and download the IntelliJ IDEA Community or Ultimate edition based on...

General

Development of Funny H5 Game - Toy Claw

by: kcodez | last post by:

As a H5 game development enthusiast, I recently wrote a very interesting little game - Toy Claw ((http://claw.kjeek.com/))。Here I will summarize and share the development experience here, and hope it...

HTML / CSS

How to insert a new record in a database

by: Taofi | last post by:

I try to insert a new record but the error message says the number of query names and destination fields are not the same This are my field names ID, Budgeted, Actual, Status and Differences ...

DB2 Database

Cancel Print Action if Sub form has No Records

by: DJRhino1175 | last post by:

When I run this code I get an error, its Run-time error# 424 Object required...This is my first attempt at doing something like this. I test the entire code and it worked until I added this - If...

Microsoft Access / VBA

To verify entry of a dropdown

by: DJRhino | last post by:

Private Sub CboDrawingID_BeforeUpdate(Cancel As Integer) If = 310029923 Or 310030138 Or 310030152 Or 310030346 Or 310030348 Or _ 310030356 Or 310030359 Or 310030362 Or...

Microsoft Access / VBA

React to native button blinking effect

by: lllomh | last post by:

Define the method first this.state = { buttonBackgroundColor: 'green', isBlinking: false, // A new status is added to identify whether the button is blinking or not } autoStart=()=>{

Software Development

Windows 11 and Access Combo Box Issue

by: DJRhino | last post by:

Was curious if anyone else was having this same issue or not.... I was just Up/Down graded to windows 11 and now my access combo boxes are not acting right. With win 10 I could start typing...

Microsoft Access / VBA

Similar topics