This sounds like the web server that you are hosting the website on isn't configured properly. I think this sort of thing happens when your server's not set up to use ASP pages....it just treats it as a file instead of as a request to service a page.
Check your web server (IIS?) settings to make sure that your web site is configured to use ASP.
-Frinny
Ok, just bear with me for a minute.....
I read the information file on our host before I started trying to move the site over, it listed what names it will recognize as a home page (i.e. index.html, index.htm) it didn't list ASPX.
But I tried it anyways, deleated all the old HTML files and moved all the aspx files over. It just took me to the root directory in the browser when I only had the default.aspx file and all the other aspx files in there.
So........and this is probably bad - but I created a blank index.html page that in one second, redirects you to the aspx page.
And that loaded in the browser fine, but......the links off of the default.aspx page, or otherwise new home page were wanting to download and not display.
After I posted this question, I changed them to regular HTML links and now the entire code that is in the narrative.aspx page is displaying in the browser without applying the template.......