equivalent code?

[haiQ]

I'm a new at C# - so please forgive my ignorance. The following 2 snippets
of code seem to be fairly equivalent. Is there any advantage to using 1 over
the other? Example 2 seems to be much more efficient...

Example 1:
XmlTextReader xtr = new
XmlTextReader(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath(" DogData.xml"));

XmlDataDocument xdd = new XmlDataDocument();
DataSet ds = xdd.DataSet;
ds.ReadXmlSchema(xtr);
xtr.Close ();

xtr = new XmlTextReader(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath(" DogData.xml"));
xdd.Load(xtr);
xtr.Close();
return ds;

Example 2:
DataSet ds = new DataSet();
ds.ReadXmlSchema(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPat h("DogData.xml"));
ds.ReadXml(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath("Dog Data.xml"));
return ds;

Thanks!
haiQ

[Sergey Dubinets]

Ex.2 is much simpler. I'd choose it.

In Ex.1 you create XmlDataDocument over DataSet and feed DataSet through it.

You may want to use XmlDataDocument to treat (access or edit) DataSet as XML
tree.

Sergey

"haiQ" <ha**@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:7E**********************************@microsof t.com...

I'm a new at C# - so please forgive my ignorance. The following 2
snippets
of code seem to be fairly equivalent. Is there any advantage to using 1
over
the other? Example 2 seems to be much more efficient...

Example 1:
XmlTextReader xtr = new
XmlTextReader(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath(" DogData.xml"));

XmlDataDocument xdd = new XmlDataDocument();
DataSet ds = xdd.DataSet;
ds.ReadXmlSchema(xtr);
xtr.Close ();

xtr = new
XmlTextReader(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath(" DogData.xml"));
xdd.Load(xtr);
xtr.Close();
return ds;

Example 2:
DataSet ds = new DataSet();
ds.ReadXmlSchema(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPat h("DogData.xml"));
ds.ReadXml(HttpContext.Current.Server.MapPath("Dog Data.xml"));
return ds;

Thanks!
haiQ