question about valid keys in JSON

[Morgan Packard]

var Functions = {
myfunction : function() { }

}

var refToFunction = Functions.myfunction;

var myJsonObj1 = {
refToFunction : "some value"
}
var myJsonObj2 = {
Functions.myfunction: "some value"
}
Can anyone explain why my browser complains when creating the second
myJsonObj2 (missing : after property id
[Break on this error] Functions.myfunction : "some value" \n)? Can I
not have dot notation in a JSON key?

thanks,

-Morgan

[Henry]

On Aug 20, 9:15 pm, Morgan Packard wrote:

var Functions = {
myfunction : function() { }

}

var refToFunction = Functions.myfunction;

var myJsonObj1 = {
refToFunction : "some value"

}

var myJsonObj2 = {
Functions.myfunction: "some value"

}

Can anyone explain why my browser complains when creating
the second myJsonObj2 ...

<snip>

The property names used in an object literal may only be Identifiers,
string literals or numeric literals (and numeric literals don't work
in some implementations (e.g. on Mac IE 5)).

>? Can I not have dot notation in a JSON key?

A property accessor is none of an Identifier, a string literal or a
numeric literal, so no you cannot. But if you want a dot in the
property name use a string literal; - {"Functions.myfunction": "some
value"} - is a legal object literal. Indeed, strictly JSON requires
the property names used to be quoted else what you have is just a
javascript object literal and not JSON at all.

[Lasse Reichstein Nielsen]

Morgan Packard <he****************@gmail.comwrites:

....

var myJsonObj2 = {
Functions.myfunction: "some value"
}
Can anyone explain why my browser complains when creating the second
myJsonObj2 (missing : after property id
[Break on this error] Functions.myfunction : "some value" \n)? Can I
not have dot notation in a JSON key?

Indeed, you cannot have a dot.

In fact, in JSON all keys *must* be quoted. I.e.:
{"refToFunction" : "some value", "Functions.myfunction": "some value"}
Many parsers for JSON will ignore this constraint, especially those using
Javascript's "eval" function.

In Javascript, keys that are also valid identifiers or number literals
may be left unquoted:
{refToFunction: "some value", "Functions.myfunction": "some value",
2: "some value", true: "some value"}

/L
--
Lasse Reichstein Nielsen
DHTML Death Colors: <URL:http://www.infimum.dk/HTML/rasterTriangleDOM.html>
'Faith without judgement merely degrades the spirit divine.'

[dhtml]

Morgan Packard wrote:

var Functions = {
myfunction : function() { }

}

In addition to the information you already got, JSON doesn't allow
function expressions for values.

JSON uses a subset of Object Literal Notation. For more details, please
see: http://www.json.org/

Garrett

thanks,

-Morgan