On Thu, 21 Sep 2006, Quasimenudo CSS wrote:
why does anyone use acrobat distiller, or whatever adobe calls that
currently? iv'e used the pdf pseudo printer drivers when somene
requested pdf format. and the result looked rather close to the
origina document in original format (only defect i noticed:
underlining widths varied in the pdf, whether read in foxit or
adobe7)
[...]
You seem to be muddling two different questions (neither of which are
particularly relevant to authoring WWW stylesheets, by the way).
"Acrobat" is software which generates PDF format. There are other
ways to generate PDF format. Do you really want to discuss Acrobat
software, or do you want to discuss PDF format itself?
Allegedly, the adobe software will produce results which are better
optimised than one gets from the third-party PDF printer drivers to
which you seem to be referring. Sometimes the difference is
considerable - but often, I've found little difference - the size of
the PDF file being dominated by other issues.
but pdf is terrible for documentation.
Funnily enough, I agree with your conclusion, even though vendors seem
to think PDF is the greatest thing since sliced bread.
The problem (as so often in webspace) seems to be that the folks who
are paying for these projects are still locked in a historic timewarp
in which the canonical document is a printed brochure, while the
online version is just a last-minute add-on which, as far as they are
concerned, needs to resemble the printed version as closely as
possible.
In the fullness of time, one hopes they'll get the idea that the
canonical document is an accessible online version, while the printed
brochure is just one of many possible formats in which the information
can be made available, depending on user needs and requirements.
But, no matter how much the folks at the "sharp end" may have already
understood this principle, they still get directed to do what their
bosses and customers demand - we have many decades of ingrained
history to overcome, and those who commission web pages do not seem
keen to un-learn what they think they already know (so often, learned
from the print shop, not from the web).
By the way, I'm not saying that formats such as PDF, Flash etc. don't
have a place in the scheme of things - for those who are able and
willing to view them. But please not as the only source of
information on the web.