Can you do if ( x < y < z ) fctn1() ; ?

[Robert]

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?
Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

[Christopher]

On Apr 22, 3:24 pm, Robert <[e-mail]:

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?
Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

The latter. If your assumed intention is correct.

[sk_usenet]

"Robert" <ir*********@gmail.comwrote in message

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?

Depends on the types of x, y and z. For integers (that you are probably
assuming) it would compile.

Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

Realize that x<y returns a bool, i.e. true or false. You then compare it
against whatever type "z" has. So the intention of "x<y<z" looks wrong.

--
http://techytalk.googlepages.com

[Pete Becker]

On 2008-04-22 16:24:14 -0400, Robert <ir*********@gmail.comsaid:

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?

Yes, both.

Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

They do two different things. People generally want the latter.

--
Pete
Roundhouse Consulting, Ltd. (www.versatilecoding.com) Author of "The
Standard C++ Library Extensions: a Tutorial and Reference
(www.petebecker.com/tr1book)

[Bo Persson]

Robert wrote:

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?
Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

It actually is valid syntax, but it doesn't do what you want. The
first comparison of "x < y < z" produces a bool result (true or false)
that is then used in the second comparison. Not good.

Stay with the second alternative!
Bo Persson

[alasham.said]

On Apr 22, 10:24 pm, Robert <[e-mail]:

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?
Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

Please do not write the main body of the article into the article
title.

As syntax goes the following is correct: if ( x < y < z ) fctn1() ;

however, it may not produce what you expect.

If x, y and z are int values, then x < y evaluates to a bool, is
converted to 0 for false, 1 for true in integral promotion, then
compared to z.

Try the following code. Your compiler should produce appropriate
warnings.

#include <iomanip>
#include <iostream>

int main()
{
std::cout << std::boolalpha << static_cast<bool>( 3 < 2 < 1 ) <<
std::endl;
std::cin.get();
}

[Pascal J. Bourguignon]

Robert <ir*********@gmail.comwrites:

Is that valid C or C++ syntax?
Or must one do x<y && y<z ?

Despite the negative overlook of the other answers, notice that:

a b a<b (b ==a) not(b ==a)
0 < 0 false true false
0 < 1 true false true
1 < 0 false true false
1 < 1 false true false

a<b <=not(b ==a)

so:

bool p=x<y<z;

stores in p: not(z ==x<y)
which may or may not be useful, depending on your problem.

That said, I would define keywords to make it clearer:

#define notimpliedby <
#define impliedby >=
#define implies <=
#define doesnotimply >

so you can write. using parentheses:

int precipitation;
int sunshine;
int temperature_celcius;
if(((precipitation<10)implies(8<sunshine))and(temp erature_celcius>20)){
cout<<"Good weather";
}else{
cout<<"Let's go south";
}

--
__Pascal Bourguignon__