By using this site, you agree to our updated Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Manage your Cookies Settings.
446,190 Members | 833 Online
Bytes IT Community
+ Ask a Question
Need help? Post your question and get tips & solutions from a community of 446,190 IT Pros & Developers. It's quick & easy.

operator>> for numbers: stream state after failed read

P: n/a

Does the C++ standard require
std::basic_istream<>::operator>>(double&) to leave the input stream
untouched in case of a read failure?

I noticed an unexpected behavior of operator>>() for numbers (double,
int) when reading from cin. I would like to ask for expert
clarification on whether I am misunderstanding the rules of the game,
or whether my library implementation has a bug. I tested this on g++
4.1.1 under Linux, g++ 3.4.5 MinGW and cxx 7.1 under Tru64 Unix
(behavior there is slightly different than described below). I checked
Josuttis "The C++ Standard Library" and the C++ standard ch 22.2.2 and
27.6.1, but haven't been able to get anything useful out of them.

The problem is as follows: If would like to read sequences like "1 2
+" by first trying to read into a double, and if that fails try to
read into a char, see sample program below (the program reads only a
single number/symbol). This works fine as long as any non-number token
is not a symbol that could be the first symbol in a number, i.e. the
plus sign, the minus sign or the decimal point. If the symbol is one
of those three, the program simply hangs. If I change the locale to,
e.g., Norwegian, it will hang on the decimal comma instead of the
decimal point.

My interpretation is that the operator reads +, -, or ., then tries to
read the next digit, which it does not find, and then raises the
failbit and returns WITHOUT putting +, -, or . back into the input
stream. Should this/must this be so?

A work-around presumably is to read to a string, place it into a
stringstream and then extract from the latter.

I'd appreciate expert advice on this.

Illustrate problems with symbols that can
be prefixes to numbers (+,-,. if no locale is set).

If a number is entered on the keyboard, the program prints
OK --- double: -1.3

If any characted but + - . is entered, the program prints
FAIL --- double
OK --- char: a

If + - or . are entered, the program hangs after
FAIL --- double

#include <iostream>
using namespace std;
int main()
double x = 0;
char c = 0;

if ( cin >x )
cerr << "OK --- double: " << x << endl;
cerr << "FAIL --- double" << endl;;
if ( cin >c )
cerr << "OK --- char: " << c << endl;
cerr << "FAIL --- char" << endl;

return 0;

Mar 21 '07 #1
Share this question for a faster answer!
Share on Google+

This discussion thread is closed

Replies have been disabled for this discussion.