Runtime polymorphism with references

[doina]

Hello,

Can I have runtime polymorphism using references. I knew that runtime
polymorphism could be obtained only by pointers, but now I have tried
this in Visual C++ 8.0:

#include <iostream>

using namespace std;

class Shape
{
public:
virtual void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Shape"<<endl;
};
Shape()
{
cout<<"new Shape"<<endl;
}
virtual
~Shape()
{
cout<<"delete Shape"<<endl;
}
};

class Circle: public Shape
{
public:
void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Circle"<<endl;
}
Circle()
{
cout<<"new Circle"<<endl;
}
~Circle()
{
cout<<"delete Circle"<<endl;
}
};

int main()
{
Circle c;
Shape &s = c;
s.draw();

return 0;
}

What I get is:

new Shape
new Circle
Draw Circle
delete Circle
delete Shape

So, can I have runtime polymorphism with references?
The same output happens in g++. (version 3.3.1)

Thanks,
Doina Babu

[Ondra Holub]

doina napsal:

Hello,

Can I have runtime polymorphism using references. I knew that runtime
polymorphism could be obtained only by pointers, but now I have tried
this in Visual C++ 8.0:

#include <iostream>

using namespace std;

class Shape
{
public:
virtual void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Shape"<<endl;
};
Shape()
{
cout<<"new Shape"<<endl;
}
virtual
~Shape()
{
cout<<"delete Shape"<<endl;
}
};

class Circle: public Shape
{
public:
void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Circle"<<endl;
}
Circle()
{
cout<<"new Circle"<<endl;
}
~Circle()
{
cout<<"delete Circle"<<endl;
}
};

int main()
{
Circle c;
Shape &s = c;
s.draw();

return 0;
}

What I get is:

new Shape
new Circle
Draw Circle
delete Circle
delete Shape

So, can I have runtime polymorphism with references?
The same output happens in g++. (version 3.3.1)

Thanks,
Doina Babu

Yes, it is correct in C++.

[terminator]

doina wrote:

Hello,

Can I have runtime polymorphism using references. I knew that runtime
polymorphism could be obtained only by pointers, but now I have tried
this in Visual C++ 8.0:

#include <iostream>

using namespace std;

class Shape
{
public:
virtual void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Shape"<<endl;
};
Shape()
{
cout<<"new Shape"<<endl;
}
virtual
~Shape()
{
cout<<"delete Shape"<<endl;
}
};

class Circle: public Shape
{
public:
void draw()
{
cout<<"Draw Circle"<<endl;
}
Circle()
{
cout<<"new Circle"<<endl;
}
~Circle()
{
cout<<"delete Circle"<<endl;
}
};

int main()
{
Circle c;
Shape &s = c;
s.draw();

return 0;
}

What I get is:

new Shape
new Circle
Draw Circle
delete Circle
delete Shape

So, can I have runtime polymorphism with references?
The same output happens in g++. (version 3.3.1)

Thanks,
Doina Babu

new to c++?
that certainly works .
have fun.
why do u call it runtime polymorphism?
heared anything about compile time polymorphism???

[doina]

terminator wrote:

new to c++?

no

that certainly works .

Yes, I know it works. It's what I said in my first post. :) I was
looking for an explanation (not just for valuable words... )

why do u call it runtime polymorphism?

I called it runtime polymorphism because the decision as to which
version of a method will be executed is based on the actual type of
object whose reference is stored in the reference variable, and not on
the type of the reference variable on which the method is invoked.
That's runtime polymorphism.
Until now, I was using pointers to have runtime polymorphism, like
this:
Shape *s = new Circle();
s->draw();
delete s;

I guess since references are also pointers internally, this means it
should work for references too.

heared anything about compile time polymorphism???

Why is it compile-time polymorphism?
How does it know the compiler that s is actually a Circle object and
not a Shape ... at compile time... ?
Indeed, I can use compile-time polymorphism and increase performance
but in another implementation ... one using templates...

Regards,
Doina Babu

[terminator]

doina wrote:

terminator wrote:

new to c++?

no

that certainly works .

Yes, I know it works. It's what I said in my first post. :) I was
looking for an explanation (not just for valuable words... )

why do u call it runtime polymorphism?

I called it runtime polymorphism because the decision as to which
version of a method will be executed is based on the actual type of
object whose reference is stored in the reference variable, and not on
the type of the reference variable on which the method is invoked.
That's runtime polymorphism.
Until now, I was using pointers to have runtime polymorphism, like
this:
Shape *s = new Circle();
s->draw();
delete s;

I guess since references are also pointers internally, this means it
should work for references too.

heared anything about compile time polymorphism???

Why is it compile-time polymorphism?
How does it know the compiler that s is actually a Circle object and
not a Shape ... at compile time... ?
Indeed, I can use compile-time polymorphism and increase performance
but in another implementation ... one using templates...

Regards,
Doina Babu

A persian proverb says that its wrong to ask if u already know the
answer.
u r partially right but references r not always treated as internal
pointers
auto-optimiation might remove unneccesary code.

[Marcus Kwok]

terminator <fa***********@gmail.comwrote:

heared anything about compile time polymorphism???

Templates are sometimes referred to as "compile-time polymorphism".

--
Marcus Kwok
Replace 'invalid' with 'net' to reply

[terminator]

Marcus Kwok wrote:

terminator <fa***********@gmail.comwrote:

heared anything about compile time polymorphism???

Templates are sometimes referred to as "compile-time polymorphism".

--
Marcus Kwok
Replace 'invalid' with 'net' to reply

Hmmm.I should have guessed.

thx 4 remark.

[eriwik]

On Nov 22, 4:25 pm, "doina" <[e-mail]:

terminator wrote:

new to c++?no

that certainly works .Yes, I know it works. It's what I said in my first post. :) I was

looking for an explanation (not just for valuable words... )

Explanation of what? Why it works? Because C++ is designed to work that
way, in fact when using exceptions you should always catch by reference
because of polymorfism. Whoever told you that pointers is the only way
was wrong, and now you know better than him.

--
Erik Wikström