strings in #if 0

[tedu]

having read the section on preprocessing (6.10) and not finding the
answer, is the following code acceptable? i have compilers which
accept it, accept it with a warning, and refuse to compile it. i'm
wondering which is correct.

#if 0
print FILEPTR "int main()

#endif

[Ben Pfaff]

"tedu" <[e-mail]> writes:

having read the section on preprocessing (6.10) and not finding the
answer, is the following code acceptable? i have compilers which
accept it, accept it with a warning, and refuse to compile it. i'm
wondering which is correct.

#if 0
print FILEPTR "int main()

#endif

It is incorrect. Groups that are skipped must consist of valid
preprocessing tokens.
--
"C has its problems, but a language designed from scratch would have some too,
and we know C's problems."
--Bjarne Stroustrup

[Neil]

Ben Pfaff wrote:

"tedu" <[e-mail]> writes:

having read the section on preprocessing (6.10) and not finding the
answer, is the following code acceptable? i have compilers which
accept it, accept it with a warning, and refuse to compile it. i'm
wondering which is correct.

#if 0
print FILEPTR "int main()

#endif

It is incorrect. Groups that are skipped must consist of valid
preprocessing tokens.

No, it is fine. The group consists of valid preprocessing tokens, one
of which is ". These preprocessing tokens must be ignored as the
standard dictates.

A compiler must accept it.

[Keith Thompson]

"Neil" <ne**@daikokuya.co.uk> writes:

Ben Pfaff wrote:

"tedu" <[e-mail]> writes:

> having read the section on preprocessing (6.10) and not finding the
> answer, is the following code acceptable? i have compilers which
> accept it, accept it with a warning, and refuse to compile it. i'm
> wondering which is correct.
>
> #if 0
> print FILEPTR "int main()
>
> #endif

It is incorrect. Groups that are skipped must consist of valid
preprocessing tokens.

No, it is fine. The group consists of valid preprocessing tokens, one
of which is ". These preprocessing tokens must be ignored as the
standard dictates.

A compiler must accept it.

No, it's undefined behavior. (We've had a claim that it's illegal,
and one that it's legal; I figured we should cover all the
possibilities.)

C99 6.4p3:

A _token_ is the minimal lexical element of the language in
translation phases 7 and 8. The categories of tokens are:
keywords, identifiers, constants, string literals, and
punctuators. A preprocessing token is the minimal lexical element
of the language in translation phases 3 through 6. The categories
of preprocessing tokens are: header names, identifiers,
preprocessing numbers, character constants, string literals,
punctuators, and single non-white-space characters that do not
lexically match the other preprocessing token categories. If a '
or a " character matches the last category, the behavior is
undefined.

--
Keith Thompson (The_Other_Keith) ks***@mib.org <http://www.ghoti.net/~kst>
San Diego Supercomputer Center <*> <http://users.sdsc.edu/~kst>
We must do something. This is something. Therefore, we must do this.

[Richard Bos]

"Neil" <ne**@daikokuya.co.uk> wrote:

Ben Pfaff wrote:

"tedu" <[e-mail]> writes:

having read the section on preprocessing (6.10) and not finding the
answer, is the following code acceptable? i have compilers which
accept it, accept it with a warning, and refuse to compile it. i'm
wondering which is correct.

#if 0
print FILEPTR "int main()

#endif

It is incorrect. Groups that are skipped must consist of valid
preprocessing tokens.

No, it is fine. The group consists of valid preprocessing tokens, one
of which is ". These preprocessing tokens must be ignored as the
standard dictates.

A compiler must accept it.

Wrong, and wrong. From 6.4#3:

# The categories of preprocessing tokens are: ... string literals ... ,
# and single non-whitespace characters that do not lexically match the
# other preprocessing token categories. If a ' or " character matches
# the last category, the behavior is undefined.

Note the last sentence.

Richard