Shouldn't throw built-in exceptions?

[Joe Van Dyk]

The FAQ at
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit....html#faq-17.6 says that
you shouldn't throw built-in exceptions.

I'm not sure why I shouldn't throw something like std::domain_error
though -- if it does all that I want it to do.

Joe

[Victor Bazarov]

Joe Van Dyk wrote:

The FAQ at
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit....html#faq-17.6 says
that you shouldn't throw built-in exceptions.
The FAQ says nothing of the kind. Read it again. It recommends against
throwing built-in _types_ (like 'int' or 'char*'), not standard exceptions.
I'm not sure why I shouldn't throw something like std::domain_error
though -- if it does all that I want it to do.

By all means, throw it.

V
--
Please remove capital 'A's when replying by e-mail
I do not respond to top-posted replies, please don't ask

[Jakob Bieling]

Joe Van Dyk <jo********@boeing.com> wrote:

The FAQ at
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit....html#faq-17.6 says
that you shouldn't throw built-in exceptions.

I'm not sure why I shouldn't throw something like std::domain_error
though -- if it does all that I want it to do.

It did not say 'do not throw built-in exceptions' but 'do not throw
built-ins'. A built-in [type] is an 'int' or a 'char*'. At least how I
understood this. I do not see anything wrong with throwing an
std::runtime_exception, if it suits your needs

hth
--
jb

(reply address in rot13, unscramble first)

[Jakob Bieling]

Jakob Bieling <ar****************@rot13.com> wrote:

understood this. I do not see anything wrong with throwing an
std::runtime_exception, if it suits your needs

Err, std::runtime_error ;-)
--
jb

(reply address in rot13, unscramble first)

[Joe Van Dyk]

Victor Bazarov wrote:

Joe Van Dyk wrote:

The FAQ at
http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lit....html#faq-17.6 says
that you shouldn't throw built-in exceptions.

The FAQ says nothing of the kind. Read it again. It recommends against
throwing built-in _types_ (like 'int' or 'char*'), not standard exceptions.

I'm not sure why I shouldn't throw something like std::domain_error
though -- if it does all that I want it to do.

By all means, throw it.

V

Ah, ok. They gave an example of throwing an exception object that
inherits from a standard exception, so I thought that's what the FAQ was
saying.

Thanks!
Joe