Using a fstream reference with getline

[Peter Gordon]

Is using getline with a fstream reference covered in the standard?

I have three C++ compilers on my system. Two of them compile
the code below without warnings. The third returns the following
error:
t1.cpp:
Error E2285 t1.cpp 14: Could not find a match for
'std::getline<charT,traits,Allocator>(std::ifstrea m,std::string)'
in function A::readfun()
*** 1 errors in Compile ***

If the fstream is not a reference, it compiles without complaint.

BTW, yeah, I know, I haven't opened a file etc. I've
tried to skinny the code down to the minimum that
produes the error.

#include <fstream>
#include <string>

class A {
public:
A(std::ifstream& _inH) : inH(_inH) {}
void readfun();
void readfun1();
private:
std::ifstream& inH;
};
void A::readfun() {
std::string buf;
std::getline(inH, buf);
}
int main() {
std::ifstream fin;
class A x(fin);
return 0;
}

[Mike Wahler]

"Peter Gordon" <petergo@_deleteme_.netspace.net.au> wrote in message
news:Xn**********************************@203.10.1 10.105...

Is using getline with a fstream reference covered in the standard?
Yes.
I have three C++ compilers on my system. Two of them compile
the code below without warnings. The third returns the following
error:
t1.cpp:
Error E2285 t1.cpp 14: Could not find a match for
'std::getline<charT,traits,Allocator>(std::ifstrea m,std::string)'
in function A::readfun()
'std::getline()'s first parameter is type 'std::ifstream&' (that is,
a reference), not 'std::ifstream' (an object).
*** 1 errors in Compile ***

If the fstream is not a reference, it compiles without complaint.
Again, 'std::getline()'s first parameter is a reference.

Which compiler is giving that error message?

BTW, yeah, I know, I haven't opened a file etc. I've
tried to skinny the code down to the minimum that
produes the error.
That's what we like. :-)

#include <fstream>
#include <string>

class A {
public:
A(std::ifstream& _inH) : inH(_inH) {}
void readfun();
void readfun1();
private:
std::ifstream& inH;
};
void A::readfun() {
std::string buf;
std::getline(inH, buf);
}
int main() {
std::ifstream fin;
class A x(fin);
The keyword 'class' is redundant (but harmless) here.
return 0;
}

The code looks OK to me. (But of course the call to 'getline()'
will always fail, since you didn't open the stream).

-Mike

[Peter Gordon]

"Mike Wahler" <mk******@mkwahler.net> wrote in news:UKtZd.9167$oO4.3964
@newsread3.news.pas.earthlink.net:

"Peter Gordon" <petergo@_deleteme_.netspace.net.au> wrote in message
news:Xn**********************************@203.10.1 10.105...

Is using getline with a fstream reference covered in the standard?

Yes.

I have three C++ compilers on my system. Two of them compile
the code below without warnings. The third returns the following
error:
t1.cpp:
Error E2285 t1.cpp 14: Could not find a match for
'std::getline<charT,traits,Allocator>(std::ifstrea m,std::string)'
in function A::readfun()

'std::getline()'s first parameter is type 'std::ifstream&' (that is,
a reference), not 'std::ifstream' (an object).

*** 1 errors in Compile ***

If the fstream is not a reference, it compiles without complaint.

Again, 'std::getline()'s first parameter is a reference.

Which compiler is giving that error message?

Borland Ver 55 which is their free download and is dated
about 2000.

I have a registered copy of CBuilder 4.
The following code compiled and linked on it.

void A::readfun() {
std::string buf;
ifstream inH1;
inH1 = inH;
std::getline(inH1, buf);
}

I didn't try to run it. <g>

So I downloaded the later version and it wouldn't
let me re-asign a reference thus, at least it is an
improvement.
I