Monitor.Enter/Exit Question

[Rudi]

Hi

I've got a CollectData() method which is called by Timer periodically.
CollectData calls Add(input) - the problem is the code after Add(input) in
CollectData() is never executed. It's as if the monitor is never closed.
CollectData() never executes further then Add(input), except I remove the
monitors. It's an Windows CE 5.0 application.

What is my problem? Hope someone can help.

Thanks!

....
protected void CollectData(object oState)
{
Add(input);
.... // code after Add(input)
Do(input); //if some condition met then Do()
...
}

....
public void Add(string input)
{
try
{
Monitor.Enter(strAdded);
this.strAdded += input;
}
catch (Exception oException)
{
throw oException;
}
finally
{
Monitor.Exit(strAdded);
}
}
....

[Markus Stoeger]

Rudi wrote:

Hi

I've got a CollectData() method which is called by Timer periodically.
CollectData calls Add(input) - the problem is the code after Add(input) in
CollectData() is never executed. It's as if the monitor is never closed.
CollectData() never executes further then Add(input), except I remove the
monitors. It's an Windows CE 5.0 application.

What is my problem? Hope someone can help.

What kind of timer are you calling the CollectData method from (there
are three timers in the framework)? Does this timer fire from another
thread?

I think the problem is that the strAdded object gets changed by the +=
operator (as strings can't be modified, += returns a completely new
string / new object instead).

So in effect you are calling Monitor.Enter and Monitor.Exit on two
different objects and the Monitor will never be released on the initial
object.. which can lead to the dead lock you are experiencing.

Try to lock on some object that does not change and see if that helps!

hth,
Max

[Rudi]

Thanks!!

That helped. It was the object I was locking.
"Markus Stoeger" wrote:

Rudi wrote:

Hi

I've got a CollectData() method which is called by Timer periodically.
CollectData calls Add(input) - the problem is the code after Add(input) in
CollectData() is never executed. It's as if the monitor is never closed.
CollectData() never executes further then Add(input), except I remove the
monitors. It's an Windows CE 5.0 application.

What is my problem? Hope someone can help.

What kind of timer are you calling the CollectData method from (there
are three timers in the framework)? Does this timer fire from another
thread?

I think the problem is that the strAdded object gets changed by the +=
operator (as strings can't be modified, += returns a completely new
string / new object instead).

So in effect you are calling Monitor.Enter and Monitor.Exit on two
different objects and the Monitor will never be released on the initial
object.. which can lead to the dead lock you are experiencing.

Try to lock on some object that does not change and see if that helps!

hth,
Max

[Jon Skeet [C# MVP]]

Rudi <Ru**@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

That helped. It was the object I was locking.

Note that if you use lock(...) instead of calling Monitor.Enter/Exit,
the compiler makes sure you lock/unlock the same reference anyway.

In your case, the code would be:

public void Add(string input)
{
lock (strAdded)
{
strAdded += input;
}
}

Locking on that monitor is a bad idea anyway though, precisely because
you're changing the variable value. See
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet/csharp/t...ckchoice.shtml

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.com>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet Blog: http://www.msmvps.com/jon.skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too