Enum 'aliasing' and ToString()

[Jon Shemitz]

Let's say I have an enum like

public enum Aliased {A = 0, B, C, Lowest = A, Highest = C};

and a variable

Aliased Variable = Aliased.C;

When I do Variable.ToString() in simple test code, I get "C". Yet, in
a real app, in similar code, I get the equivalent of "Highest" - ie, I
get the aliased name, not the 'primary' name.

My less important question is: Why the difference between the two? Why
isn't it ALWAYS the first defined or ALWAYS the last defined or ALWAYS
the first alphabetically?

My real question: Is there a way to control which name ToString will
use? I'd expect something like an attribute that I can apply to an
enum member

public enum Aliased
{
A = 0, B, C,
[NoName] Lowest = A,
[NoName] Highest = C
};

.... but there doesn't seem to be anything of the sort?

--

www.midnightbeach.com

[Jon Skeet [C# MVP]]

Jon Shemitz <jo*@midnightbeach.com> wrote:

Let's say I have an enum like

public enum Aliased {A = 0, B, C, Lowest = A, Highest = C};

and a variable

Aliased Variable = Aliased.C;

When I do Variable.ToString() in simple test code, I get "C". Yet, in
a real app, in similar code, I get the equivalent of "Highest" - ie, I
get the aliased name, not the 'primary' name.

My less important question is: Why the difference between the two? Why
isn't it ALWAYS the first defined or ALWAYS the last defined or ALWAYS
the first alphabetically?
I suspect it may well have something to do with hashcodes, but either
way, it's not defined.
My real question: Is there a way to control which name ToString will
use? I'd expect something like an attribute that I can apply to an
enum member

I don't believe there's any way of doing it.

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.com>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too

[Paul E Collins]

"Jon Skeet [C# MVP]" <sk***@pobox.com> wrote:

[ToString is inconsistent with enum items]
Is there a way to control which name ToString will
use? I'd expect something like an attribute that I can
apply to an enum member

I don't believe there's any way of doing it.

It's not especially elegant, but as a workaround you could apply a
DescriptionAttribute to each enum element and use that description
rather than calling ToString.

P.

[Jon Shemitz]

"Jon Skeet [C# MVP]" wrote:

My less important question is: Why the difference between the two? Why
isn't it ALWAYS the first defined or ALWAYS the last defined or ALWAYS
the first alphabetically?

I suspect it may well have something to do with hashcodes, but either
way, it's not defined.

Thanks, Jon. You definitely deserve that MVP.

My real question: Is there a way to control which name ToString will
use? I'd expect something like an attribute that I can apply to an
enum member

I don't believe there's any way of doing it.

Thanks. That's what I thought; I switched the code to put the aliases
into a second enum.

--

www.midnightbeach.com