How can I hide base class members that are public

[C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two]

Hi,

I have a C# class libary (Class1) which is inherited by another class in a
Windows Forms app. I want this other class to implement some, but not all of
the features of the base class. How can I completely hide (within the IDE)
the members of the base class library i.e. only expose those members that I
want exposed? I've tried some methods gleaned by googling for "hiding base
class members" which suggested using things like "new" and a blank function
structure but this doesn't apparently work. The only idea I've come up with
is not to inherit the base class but simply create an instance of it and use
that instead and then create only the methods and properties that I need in
my derived class. This at the moment seems to be the most logical solution,
but it also seems like a lot of extra work, does anyone know of a better
way. I basically want it to work like using interfaces, you know, expose and
hide what you want as appropriate.

Thanks

Greg

[michael]

Can you not just make Class1 an interface and make those methods that you
wish not be to re-implemented as "private"? Nonetheless, it really sounds
like you should be moving those common methods to an interface of its own
(e.x ClassInterface) and then have Class1 implement on that common class
(Class1 : ClassInterface).

Hope this helps.
"C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two" <no***@noneofyourbusiness.com> wrote
in message news:OH****************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

Hi,

I have a C# class libary (Class1) which is inherited by another class in a
Windows Forms app. I want this other class to implement some, but not all of the features of the base class. How can I completely hide (within the IDE)
the members of the base class library i.e. only expose those members that I want exposed? I've tried some methods gleaned by googling for "hiding base
class members" which suggested using things like "new" and a blank function structure but this doesn't apparently work. The only idea I've come up with is not to inherit the base class but simply create an instance of it and use that instead and then create only the methods and properties that I need in my derived class. This at the moment seems to be the most logical solution, but it also seems like a lot of extra work, does anyone know of a better
way. I basically want it to work like using interfaces, you know, expose and hide what you want as appropriate.

Thanks

Greg

[C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two]

Hi Michael,

I don't think I can make Class1 an interface as it is a fully useable class
by itself. Class2 builds upon it and hides some of it's unused features for
this specific application. Your thoughts?

Regards

Greg

"michael" <mp********@sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
news:uw*****************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

Can you not just make Class1 an interface and make those methods that you
wish not be to re-implemented as "private"? Nonetheless, it really sounds
like you should be moving those common methods to an interface of its own
(e.x ClassInterface) and then have Class1 implement on that common class
(Class1 : ClassInterface).

Hope this helps.
"C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two" <no***@noneofyourbusiness.com> wrote in message news:OH****************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

Hi,

I have a C# class libary (Class1) which is inherited by another class in a Windows Forms app. I want this other class to implement some, but not all

of

the features of the base class. How can I completely hide (within the

IDE) the members of the base class library i.e. only expose those members that I

want exposed? I've tried some methods gleaned by googling for "hiding

base class members" which suggested using things like "new" and a blank

function

structure but this doesn't apparently work. The only idea I've come up

with

is not to inherit the base class but simply create an instance of it and

use

that instead and then create only the methods and properties that I need

in

my derived class. This at the moment seems to be the most logical

solution,

but it also seems like a lot of extra work, does anyone know of a better
way. I basically want it to work like using interfaces, you know, expose

and

hide what you want as appropriate.

Thanks

Greg

[Jon Skeet [C# MVP]]

C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two <no***@noneofyourbusiness.com>
wrote:

I have a C# class libary (Class1) which is inherited by another class in a
Windows Forms app. I want this other class to implement some, but not all of
the features of the base class. How can I completely hide (within the IDE)
the members of the base class library i.e. only expose those members that I
want exposed?
You can't. If you don't want people to have access to the base class's
members, don't inherit from it. Have a search for Liskov's
Substitutability Principle for good reasons for this.
I've tried some methods gleaned by googling for "hiding base
class members" which suggested using things like "new" and a blank function
structure but this doesn't apparently work. The only idea I've come up with
is not to inherit the base class but simply create an instance of it and use
that instead and then create only the methods and properties that I need in
my derived class. This at the moment seems to be the most logical solution,
Yup, it is.
but it also seems like a lot of extra work, does anyone know of a better
way. I basically want it to work like using interfaces, you know, expose and
hide what you want as appropriate.

Composition can be a bit of extra work, but gives a lot of flexibility
and can avoid unintended uses of your class.

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.com>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too

[C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two]

Hi Jon,

Thanks for clearing that up for me. Some drudge work to do, but not too
much of a problem, at least I don't have to rewrite the implementation
stuff. I have to admit to not having every heard of "Liskov's
Substitutability Principle". Just had a quick look on Google for it and
found a simplified explanation. Which explains it well enough.

Regards

Greg

"Jon Skeet [C# MVP]" <sk***@pobox.com> wrote in message
news:MP***********************@msnews.microsoft.co m...

C-Sharper or C-Hasher, one of the two <no***@noneofyourbusiness.com>
wrote:

I have a C# class libary (Class1) which is inherited by another class in a Windows Forms app. I want this other class to implement some, but not all of the features of the base class. How can I completely hide (within the IDE) the members of the base class library i.e. only expose those members that I want exposed?
You can't. If you don't want people to have access to the base class's
members, don't inherit from it. Have a search for Liskov's
Substitutability Principle for good reasons for this.

I've tried some methods gleaned by googling for "hiding base
class members" which suggested using things like "new" and a blank function structure but this doesn't apparently work. The only idea I've come up with is not to inherit the base class but simply create an instance of it and use that instead and then create only the methods and properties that I need in my derived class. This at the moment seems to be the most logical solution,
Yup, it is.

but it also seems like a lot of extra work, does anyone know of a better
way. I basically want it to work like using interfaces, you know, expose

and hide what you want as appropriate.

Composition can be a bit of extra work, but gives a lot of flexibility
and can avoid unintended uses of your class.

--
Jon Skeet - <sk***@pobox.com>
http://www.pobox.com/~skeet
If replying to the group, please do not mail me too