Synchronizing a ListDictionary

[Allen Jones]

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version
named SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me that
I "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,
abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as virtual
in the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the compiler
doesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

[Jon Davis]

Try using "new". It doesn't override the virtual method, but it will be
called when referenced in the context of your customized class.

Jon
"Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com> wrote in message
news:eW**************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version
named SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me that I "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,
abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as virtual in the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the compiler doesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

[Allen Jones]

Hi Jon,

Thanks for the input, but as I said in my post, I am not after work arounds
or alternatives. I want to understand why this does not work the way it
should.

Regards
Allen

"Jon Davis" <jo*@REMOVE.ME.PLEASE.jondavis.net> wrote in message
news:us**************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

Try using "new". It doesn't override the virtual method, but it will be
called when referenced in the context of your customized class.

Jon
"Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com> wrote in message
news:eW**************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version named SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me

that

I "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual, abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as

virtual

in the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the

compiler

doesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

[Austin Ehlers]

On Sat, 19 Jul 2003 15:42:01 +0100, "Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com>
wrote:

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version
named SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me that
I "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,
abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as virtual
in the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the compiler
doesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

How did you override it? Using VS2003, this works:
public class MyDict:ListDictionary,IDictionary
{
public MyDict()
{
}
private class myDict:IDictionary
}
When you type myDict:IDictionary, VS will show a little tip that says:
"Press TAB to implement stubs for interface
System.Collections.IDictionary"

Does that work for you?

[Allen Jones]

Austin,

Its the individual members that cause a problem when I compile them. e.g.

public class SynchronizedListDictionary : ListDictionary {

// other stuff

public override void Add(object key, object value) {
// method implementation
}
}

In the example the Add method causes the compiler to report the message:
Add(object, object) canot override
System.Collections.Specialized.ListDictionary.Add( object,object) because it
is not marked virtual, abstract, or override.

The problem is, according to the docs, ListDictionary.Add IS virtual.

Regards
Allen

"Austin Ehlers" <th***********************@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:8g********************************@4ax.com...

On Sat, 19 Jul 2003 15:42:01 +0100, "Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com>
wrote:

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version
named SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me thatI "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,
abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as virtualin the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the compilerdoesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

How did you override it? Using VS2003, this works:
public class MyDict:ListDictionary,IDictionary
{
public MyDict()
{
}
private class myDict:IDictionary
}
When you type myDict:IDictionary, VS will show a little tip that says:
"Press TAB to implement stubs for interface
System.Collections.IDictionary"

Does that work for you?

[Simon Trew]

Yes, I have tried it & I agree there seems to be a discrepancy between the
docs and real life.

I appreciate you are not looking for workarounds, but just for information,
you can override the interface explicitly i.e.:

void IDictionary.Add(object key, object value);

However, this may not be ideal in all circumstances.

S.

"Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com> wrote in message
news:e4**************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

Austin,

Its the individual members that cause a problem when I compile them. e.g.

public class SynchronizedListDictionary : ListDictionary {

// other stuff

public override void Add(object key, object value) {
// method implementation
}
}

In the example the Add method causes the compiler to report the message:
Add(object, object) canot override
System.Collections.Specialized.ListDictionary.Add( object,object) because it is not marked virtual, abstract, or override.

The problem is, according to the docs, ListDictionary.Add IS virtual.

Regards
Allen

"Austin Ehlers" <th***********************@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:8g********************************@4ax.com...

On Sat, 19 Jul 2003 15:42:01 +0100, "Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com>
wrote:

Hi,

I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe versionnamed SynchronizedListDictionary.

Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary arevirtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells me thatI "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,abstract, or override".

I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed as virtualin the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but the compilerdoesnt recognize it as such.

Thanks

Regards
Allen

How did you override it? Using VS2003, this works:
public class MyDict:ListDictionary,IDictionary
{
public MyDict()
{
}
private class myDict:IDictionary
}
When you type myDict:IDictionary, VS will show a little tip that says:
"Press TAB to implement stubs for interface
System.Collections.IDictionary"

Does that work for you?

[Austin Ehlers]

Well. looking at the rotor source code, it does appear that the
documentation is wrong. It's declared as:

public void Add(object key, object value)
{
//stuff
}

So, it's another error in the documentation.
On Mon, 21 Jul 2003 09:19:32 +0100, "Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com>
wrote:

Austin,

Its the individual members that cause a problem when I compile them. e.g.

public class SynchronizedListDictionary : ListDictionary {

// other stuff

public override void Add(object key, object value) { // method implementation
}
}

In the example the Add method causes the compiler to report the message:
Add(object, object) canot override
System.Collections.Specialized.ListDictionary.Add (object,object) because it
is not marked virtual, abstract, or override.

The problem is, according to the docs, ListDictionary.Add IS virtual.

Regards
Allen

"Austin Ehlers" <th***********************@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:8g********************************@4ax.com.. .

On Sat, 19 Jul 2003 15:42:01 +0100, "Allen Jones" <ag*@bigfoot.com>
wrote:

>Hi,
>
>I tried to extend ListDictionary in order to create a thread safe version
>named SynchronizedListDictionary.
>
>Despite the docs saying the properties and methods of ListDictionary are
>virtual, when I try to compile my derived class, the compiler tells methat >I "cannot override inherited member XXX because it is not marked virtual,
>abstract, or override".
>
>I know there are other collections and techniques that I can use as an
>alternative, but I want to understand how a method can be listed asvirtual >in the docs (which I thought came straight from the source) but thecompiler >doesnt recognize it as such.
>
>Thanks
>
>Regards
>Allen
>

How did you override it? Using VS2003, this works:
public class MyDict:ListDictionary,IDictionary
{
public MyDict()
{
}
private class myDict:IDictionary
}
When you type myDict:IDictionary, VS will show a little tip that says:
"Press TAB to implement stubs for interface
System.Collections.IDictionary"

Does that work for you?