What is the best way to make dual-way xml databinding?

[Stan]

I am looking for the best solution for this scenario:

ASP.NET needs display an editable form with 20 textboxes. Data source is
xml. Xml must be updated. if user clicks Update button on the form.

Scenario 1 - brute force

Load xml into XmlDocument,
txtName.Text = doc.SelectSingleNode ('\\bla\@bla").Value

private void OnNameChanged(object sender, System.EventArgs e)
{
doc.SelectSingleNode ("\\bla\@bla").Value = txtName.Text
}

Scenario 2 - databinind
Load DataSet from xml, hook up text box with dataset in txtName_Databinding
event I am not sure if it will work both ways.

Scenario 3 - Xml data island
I worked well in the past, not sure if it is still the best way to go..

I appreciate any opinions on that subject

-Stan

[Brock Allen]

I've not yet tried it myself, but have you considered using an XmlDataDocument?
Perhaps you can use the ObjectDataSource, build your own class that does
the Selects and Updates and then passback the XmlDataDocument as your storage
mechanism? If I had the time, it'd make for an interesting experiment.

-Brock
DevelopMentor
http://staff.develop.com/ballen

I am looking for the best solution for this scenario:

ASP.NET needs display an editable form with 20 textboxes. Data source
is xml. Xml must be updated. if user clicks Update button on the form.

Scenario 1 - brute force

Load xml into XmlDocument,
txtName.Text = doc.SelectSingleNode ('\\bla\@bla").Value
private void OnNameChanged(object sender, System.EventArgs e)
{
doc.SelectSingleNode ("\\bla\@bla").Value = txtName.Text
}
Scenario 2 - databinind
Load DataSet from xml, hook up text box with dataset in
txtName_Databinding
event I am not sure if it will work both ways.
Scenario 3 - Xml data island
I worked well in the past, not sure if it is still the best way to
go..
I appreciate any opinions on that subject

-Stan

[Stan]

I cannot use XmlDataDocument because xml comes out of sql server directly
(FOR XML EXPLICIT) and there is no dataset (doc = new XmlDataDocument (ds))

ObjectDataSource is from NET 2.0 and I forgot to mention that this is in
1.1. Yes a lot of things will be simpler in 2.0, especially xml and object
databinding

One of the problem is that even with xml databinding I can bind control on
the server, but after postback this binding is lost, similar with DataGrid.
I guess there is no magic way to do that..

"Brock Allen" <ba****@NOSPAMdevelop.com> wrote in message
news:64**********************@msnews.microsoft.com ...

I've not yet tried it myself, but have you considered using an XmlDataDocument? Perhaps you can use the ObjectDataSource, build your own class that does
the Selects and Updates and then passback the XmlDataDocument as your storage mechanism? If I had the time, it'd make for an interesting experiment.

-Brock
DevelopMentor
http://staff.develop.com/ballen

I am looking for the best solution for this scenario:

ASP.NET needs display an editable form with 20 textboxes. Data source
is xml. Xml must be updated. if user clicks Update button on the form.

Scenario 1 - brute force

Load xml into XmlDocument,
txtName.Text = doc.SelectSingleNode ('\\bla\@bla").Value
private void OnNameChanged(object sender, System.EventArgs e)
{
doc.SelectSingleNode ("\\bla\@bla").Value = txtName.Text
}
Scenario 2 - databinind
Load DataSet from xml, hook up text box with dataset in
txtName_Databinding
event I am not sure if it will work both ways.
Scenario 3 - Xml data island
I worked well in the past, not sure if it is still the best way to
go..
I appreciate any opinions on that subject

-Stan

[Brock Allen]

Oh yeah... If you're in v1.1 then there's no two-way databinding at all.
You'll have to code it all manually. Sorry.

-Brock
DevelopMentor
http://staff.develop.com/ballen

I cannot use XmlDataDocument because xml comes out of sql server
directly (FOR XML EXPLICIT) and there is no dataset (doc = new
XmlDataDocument (ds))

ObjectDataSource is from NET 2.0 and I forgot to mention that this is
in 1.1. Yes a lot of things will be simpler in 2.0, especially xml and
object databinding

One of the problem is that even with xml databinding I can bind
control on the server, but after postback this binding is lost,
similar with DataGrid. I guess there is no magic way to do that..

"Brock Allen" <ba****@NOSPAMdevelop.com> wrote in message
news:64**********************@msnews.microsoft.com ...

I've not yet tried it myself, but have you considered using an

XmlDataDocument?

Perhaps you can use the ObjectDataSource, build your own class that
does the Selects and Updates and then passback the XmlDataDocument as
your

storage

mechanism? If I had the time, it'd make for an interesting
experiment.

-Brock
DevelopMentor
http://staff.develop.com/ballen

I am looking for the best solution for this scenario:

ASP.NET needs display an editable form with 20 textboxes. Data
source is xml. Xml must be updated. if user clicks Update button on
the form.

Scenario 1 - brute force

Load xml into XmlDocument,
txtName.Text = doc.SelectSingleNode ('\\bla\@bla").Value
private void OnNameChanged(object sender, System.EventArgs e)
{
doc.SelectSingleNode ("\\bla\@bla").Value = txtName.Text
}
Scenario 2 - databinind
Load DataSet from xml, hook up text box with dataset in
txtName_Databinding
event I am not sure if it will work both ways.
Scenario 3 - Xml data island
I worked well in the past, not sure if it is still the best way to
go..
I appreciate any opinions on that subject
-Stan