About FINALLY clause

[Henri]

This question is applicable to all the languages, but could someone provide
me with an code example where FINALLY is really necessary.
FINALLY is often used for this kind of code:

Try
....
open a file
read some date
.....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
Finally
close the file
End Try

But wouldn't the following (without FINALLY) work as well?

Try
....
open a file
read some date
.....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
End Try
close the file

Please tell me what I'm missing.
Thanks
Henri

[Karl Seguin]

NO!

What happens if you can't "deal" with the file..say because the exception
was OutOfMemory (not what you thought it was going to be eh?) you should
still do what you can to close the file. Also, what happens in your
"dealing" with the exception that you decide to throw it...your close call
will never get called. The point of finally is that you are [almost]
guaranteed that the code will get called. Putting your cleanup AFTER the
try/catch doesn't provide a guarantee. Here's another case....your catch
code generates an exception...your cleanup will never get called.

Karl

--
MY ASP.Net tutorials
http://www.openmymind.net/
"Henri" <hm********@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:uM*************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

This question is applicable to all the languages, but could someone provide me with an code example where FINALLY is really necessary.
FINALLY is often used for this kind of code:

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
Finally
close the file
End Try

But wouldn't the following (without FINALLY) work as well?

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
End Try
close the file

Please tell me what I'm missing.
Thanks
Henri

[Steve C. Orr [MVP, MCSD]]

Try
....
open a file
read some date
.....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
.... exit sub or rethrow error ...
Finally
close the file
End Try

In the above code the exit sub or rethrow error would normally exit the
function, and if an error occurs within the Catch block the function would
also be exited. Anything after the try block would not be executed.
However, anything within the Finally block will be executed before the
function is exited. That is why it is useful.

--
I hope this helps,
Steve C. Orr, MCSD, MVP
http://Steve.Orr.net

"Henri" <hm********@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:uM*************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

This question is applicable to all the languages, but could someone
provide
me with an code example where FINALLY is really necessary.
FINALLY is often used for this kind of code:

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
Finally
close the file
End Try

But wouldn't the following (without FINALLY) work as well?

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
End Try
close the file

Please tell me what I'm missing.
Thanks
Henri

[DKode]

I believe if you throw an exception from your catch clause, it will not
execute code outside of your try-catch clause if you throw an exception
up the stack. Any code you put inside of finally will run whether you
throw exceptions or not regardless.

anyone correct me if i am wrong.

[Henri]

Thanks to all for your answers !
FINALLY I could understand the use of FINALLY ;-)

Henri

"Henri" <hm********@hotmail.com> a écrit dans le message de
news:uM*************@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl...

This question is applicable to all the languages, but could someone provide me with an code example where FINALLY is really necessary.
FINALLY is often used for this kind of code:

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
Finally
close the file
End Try

But wouldn't the following (without FINALLY) work as well?

Try
....
open a file
read some date
....
Catch
... dealing with the file error ....
End Try
close the file

Please tell me what I'm missing.
Thanks
Henri