best way to check whether postback or form action submit?

[Jiho Han]

What is the best way to check whether the page is simply a postback or the
form has been submit with the intention of doing something?

In the olden days, I used to check for a form field name used for the submit
button:

<input type="submit" name="saverecord" value="push me to save">

Then I'd retrieve it using something like:

' pseudo code
If Request.Form("saverecord") <> "" Then
' do action
End If

How are you guys doing this?
Thanks for any insights.
Jiho

[Curt_C [MVP]]

IsPostBack()

--
Curt Christianson
Owner/Lead Developer, DF-Software
www.Darkfalz.com
"Jiho Han" <ji******@infinityinfo.com> wrote in message
news:Oe**************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

What is the best way to check whether the page is simply a postback or the
form has been submit with the intention of doing something?

In the olden days, I used to check for a form field name used for the submit button:

<input type="submit" name="saverecord" value="push me to save">

Then I'd retrieve it using something like:

' pseudo code
If Request.Form("saverecord") <> "" Then
' do action
End If

How are you guys doing this?
Thanks for any insights.
Jiho

[Michael Ramey]

There is a difference? From my experience, if I'm "postbacking", I always
have the intention of doing something. It's how you define the different
event handlers for the controls on your page that determines what happens.
And also checking for page.ispostback in page_load to make sure you don't
repeat whatever process your page goes through the first time it is loaded.

HTH,
--Michael
"Jiho Han" <ji******@infinityinfo.com> wrote in message
news:Oe**************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

What is the best way to check whether the page is simply a postback or the
form has been submit with the intention of doing something?

In the olden days, I used to check for a form field name used for the submit button:

<input type="submit" name="saverecord" value="push me to save">

Then I'd retrieve it using something like:

' pseudo code
If Request.Form("saverecord") <> "" Then
' do action
End If

How are you guys doing this?
Thanks for any insights.
Jiho

[Jiho Han]

I didn't describe what I was trying to do clearly it seems.

Sometimes postbacks occur when you change your dropdowns or select an item
from a listbox, etc. which probably changes some state on the page but not
necessarily commit to the backend - i.e. write to DB.

That said, I realize that's what postback event handlers are for such as
button click event handler. The only thing is that I was trying to do
without the postback event handler for a particular situation. So for
example, if you have a client side button or menu item that don't have wired
event handler for some reason and submits a client side form, what would be
the best way to know whether that form was submitted for "commit" or for
"state change"? Ok, maybe we're going back in time to ASP days but I was
just wondering.

Thanks all.

"Michael Ramey" <raterus@localhost> wrote in message
news:OX**************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

There is a difference? From my experience, if I'm "postbacking", I always
have the intention of doing something. It's how you define the different
event handlers for the controls on your page that determines what happens.
And also checking for page.ispostback in page_load to make sure you don't
repeat whatever process your page goes through the first time it is loaded.
HTH,
--Michael
"Jiho Han" <ji******@infinityinfo.com> wrote in message
news:Oe**************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

What is the best way to check whether the page is simply a postback or the form has been submit with the intention of doing something?

In the olden days, I used to check for a form field name used for the

submit

button:

<input type="submit" name="saverecord" value="push me to save">

Then I'd retrieve it using something like:

' pseudo code
If Request.Form("saverecord") <> "" Then
' do action
End If

How are you guys doing this?
Thanks for any insights.
Jiho

[Michael Ramey]

"So for example, if you have a client side button or menu item that don't
have wired event handler for some reason and submits a client side form."
Can you think of any good reasons for that? I can't.

Honestly, nothing is stopping you from getting values from
Request.Form("myPostedValue"), but that is kinda old school asp there.
Everything should go through the event handlers on postbacks if you wanted
to keep with the OOP flow of the program. Gets pretty ugly if you stray
away from that.

--Michael

"Jiho Han" <ji******@infinityinfo.com> wrote in message
news:OI**************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

I didn't describe what I was trying to do clearly it seems.

Sometimes postbacks occur when you change your dropdowns or select an item
from a listbox, etc. which probably changes some state on the page but not
necessarily commit to the backend - i.e. write to DB.

That said, I realize that's what postback event handlers are for such as
button click event handler. The only thing is that I was trying to do
without the postback event handler for a particular situation. So for
example, if you have a client side button or menu item that don't have wired event handler for some reason and submits a client side form, what would be the best way to know whether that form was submitted for "commit" or for
"state change"? Ok, maybe we're going back in time to ASP days but I was
just wondering.

Thanks all.

"Michael Ramey" <raterus@localhost> wrote in message
news:OX**************@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

There is a difference? From my experience, if I'm "postbacking", I always

have the intention of doing something. It's how you define the different event handlers for the controls on your page that determines what happens. And also checking for page.ispostback in page_load to make sure you don't repeat whatever process your page goes through the first time it is

loaded.

HTH,
--Michael
"Jiho Han" <ji******@infinityinfo.com> wrote in message
news:Oe**************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

What is the best way to check whether the page is simply a postback or

the form has been submit with the intention of doing something?

In the olden days, I used to check for a form field name used for the

submit

button:

<input type="submit" name="saverecord" value="push me to save">

Then I'd retrieve it using something like:

' pseudo code
If Request.Form("saverecord") <> "" Then
' do action
End If

How are you guys doing this?
Thanks for any insights.
Jiho