"SLH" <SL*@SLH.SLHwrote in message
news:u9**************@TK2MSFTNGP04.phx.gbl...
not if you simply read from the bottom up. you know, like you do with
email
every day?
and since a lot of us use our email software to post to the newsgroups,
"top
posting" is the default (which must mean something, no?)
either way, this ridiculous conversation has gone on for years. when will
you realize 50% agree with you, 50% disagree. learn to live with the 50%
that "top post" or i suggest you dont bother reading news posts
Good point, We've allways got the option to not bother to respond to top
posters. However it helps those who are offering to help to read about an
issue in chronological order. If you want to maximise the range of people
you can get help from then the logical thing to do is to avoid top posting.
That way it is easier for someone who may have something useful to add to
jump in. Top posting tends to lock you into one or two respondants and if
your not finding their comments helpful you've kinda cut yourself off from
others who might have something helpful to add
I personally don't believe in 'laying down the law' in this regards but I
think it is reasonable for someone who is posting a lot of help to ask
'please don't top post'. For example I've responded to this bit here
without bothering to read the rest of the thread below in fact ... there
I've just cut it out. ;)