Serguei
Reading is easier, intuitive, natural because the chronological order of
messages (messages, replies, replies to replies, etc.) is easy to do, is
done from top to bottom (we all read from top to bottom) and contextual
reading, contextual comprehensiveness of the last message are preserved,
guaranteed. The readers do not have to scroll up and down all the time
to figure out what was said or replied, to understand the contextual
logic of a long discussion spread on several messages, within a thread,
among several posters. When bottom-posting is respected, the last
message of a thread keeps all the important issues of a long thread of
messages.
Bottom-posting serves the purpose of archiving and of searching among
posted messages.
In what way or why (avantages, inconvénients) bottom-posting would be
better?
>To reply after quoted material (bottom-posting) or, even better, to
reply inside the quoted message, at the spot where you want to reply
>>What do you propose then?
When you reply before quoted text, people end up reading in the
reverse order of exchanges of posted messages. We all read from top to
bottom, not from bottom to top.
>>>>What?? What are you talking about??
>It's when you reply after quoted replies
>>What's top-posting anyway?
>>>Please stop top-posting!
------------------
>>>>>>>Please stop top-posting!
>>What's top-posting anyway?
>It's when you reply after quoted replies
What?? What are you talking about??
When you reply before quoted text, people end up reading in the
reverse order of exchanges of posted messages. We all read from top to
bottom, not from bottom to top.
>>What do you propose then?
To reply after quoted material (bottom-posting) or, even better, to
reply inside the quoted message, at the spot where you want to reply
In what way or why (avantages, inconvénients) bottom-posting would be
better?
Reading is easier, intuitive, natural because the chronological order of
messages (messages, replies, replies to replies, etc.) is easy to do, is
done from top to bottom (we all read from top to bottom) and contextual
reading, contextual comprehensiveness of the last message are preserved,
guaranteed. The readers do not have to scroll up and down all the time
to figure out what was said or replied, to understand the contextual
logic of a long discussion spread on several messages, within a thread,
among several posters. When bottom-posting is respected, the last
message of a thread keeps all the important issues of a long thread of
messages.
Bottom-posting serves the purpose of archiving and of searching among
posted messages.
Gérard
--
Using Web Standards in your Web Pages (Updated Dec. 2006)
http://developer.mozilla.org/en/docs...your_Web_Pages